Thomas Dreibholz | 3 Feb 13:49 2009
Picon

Re: Last Call: draft-ietf-rserpool-mib (Reliable ServerPooling: Management Information Base using SMIv2) toExperimental RFC)

On Dienstag 27 Januar 2009, Bert Wijnen (IETF) wrote:

Dear all,

see my comments inline. Attached to this mail, you find an updated version of 
the MIB file.

> Pls note that I am not on the resepool mailing list, so send an explicit
> cc/bcc if
> you want me to see it.
>
> I am getting these SMICng (strict checking) errors/warnings:
>
> C:\bw\smicng\work>smicng rserpool.inc
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (133,4) Sequence "ENRPServerEntry" and Row
> "enrpServerEntry" should have related
> names
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (167,15) Item "enrpServerOperationScope" should have
> SIZE specified
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (272,4) Sequence "ENRPServerPoolEntry" and Row
> "enrpServerPoolEntry" should have
> related names
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (295,15) Item "enrpServerPoolHandle" should have SIZE
> specified
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (311,4) Sequence "ENRPServerPoolElementEntry" and Row
> "enrpServerPoolElementEntry
> " should have related names
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (461,4) Sequence "ENRPServerASAPAddrTableEntry" and Row
> "enrpServerASAPAddrTableE
> ntry" should have related names
(Continue reading)

Bert Wijnen (IETF | 3 Feb 17:14 2009
Picon

Re: Last Call: draft-ietf-rserpool-mib (Reliable ServerPooling: Management Information Base using SMIv2) toExperimental RFC)

Thomas, thanks for the responses.
 
W.r.t.
>> - According to RFC4181 this one
>>          rserpoolMIBConformance OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 4 }
>>    should change to
>>             rserpoolMIBConformance OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 2 }
>
> 1 is used for the ENRP servers branch, 2 is used for PE branch, 3 for PU
> branch. The next available number is 4.
The normal setup (according to rfc41`81) would be something like:
 
rserpoolMIBObjects          OBJECT-IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 1 }
rserpoolMIBConformance  OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 2 }
rserpoolENRPServers       OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 1 }
rserpoolPoolElements      OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 2 }
rserpoolPoolUsers           OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 3 }
 
Your new MIB module has no indertation at all.
Not a fatal flaw, but does not help in readability.
 
The new MIB module causes these SMICng warnings:
W: f(rserpool.mi2), (137,1) Sequence "RSerPoolENRPEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPEntry" should have related names
W: f(rserpool.mi2), (276,1) Sequence "RSerPoolENRPPoolEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPPoolEntry" should have related names
W: f(rserpool.mi2), (315,1) Sequence "RSerPoolENRPPoolElementEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry" should have related names
W: f(rserpool.mi2), (465,1) Sequence "RSerPoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry" should have related names
W: f(rserpool.mi2), (520,1) Sequence "RSerPoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry" should have related names
W: f(rserpool.mi2), (584,1) Sequence "RSerPoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry" should have related names
W: f(rserpool.mi2), (636,1) Sequence "RSerPoolENRPPeerEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPPeerEntry" should have related names
W: f(rserpool.mi2), (695,1) Sequence "RSerPoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry" should have related names
W: f(rserpool.mi2), (753,1) Sequence "RSerPoolPoolElementEntry" and Row "rserpoolPEEntry" should have related names
W: f(rserpool.mi2), (941,1) Sequence "RSerPoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry" and Row "rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry" should have related names
W: f(rserpool.mi2), (994,1) Sequence "RSerPoolPEUserAddrTableEntry" and Row "rserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry" should have related names
W: f(rserpool.mi2), (1060,1) Sequence "RSerPoolPoolUserEntry" and Row "rserpoolPUEntry" should have related names
 
*** 0 errors and 12 warnings in parsing
Probably cause by sticking to a better naming convention. Bit it would be consistent throughout.
It seems likd what you have is not absolutely incorrect. Yet... it is certainly not following the
way things are normally done.
 
I think this is more what I would expect:
 
   rserpoolENRPTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPEntry
 
Then the ENTRY spec should read like:
 
   rserpoolENRPEntry OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPEntry
 
And then:
 
   RserpoolENRPEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPIndex                Unsigned32,
 
 
Same further down in the MIB module.
 
Hope this helps,
 
Bert Wijnen
 
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Tuesday, February 03, 2009 1:49 PM
Subject: Re: [Rserpool] Last Call: draft-ietf-rserpool-mib (Reliable ServerPooling: Management Information Base using SMIv2) toExperimental RFC)

On Dienstag 27 Januar 2009, Bert Wijnen (IETF) wrote:

Dear all,

see my comments inline. Attached to this mail, you find an updated version of
the MIB file.


> Pls note that I am not on the resepool mailing list, so send an explicit
> cc/bcc if
> you want me to see it.
>
> I am getting these SMICng (strict checking) errors/warnings:
>
> C:\bw\smicng\work>smicng rserpool.inc
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (133,4) Sequence "ENRPServerEntry" and Row
> "enrpServerEntry" should have related
> names
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (167,15) Item "enrpServerOperationScope" should have
> SIZE specified
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (272,4) Sequence "ENRPServerPoolEntry" and Row
> "enrpServerPoolEntry" should have
> related names
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (295,15) Item "enrpServerPoolHandle" should have SIZE
> specified
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (311,4) Sequence "ENRPServerPoolElementEntry" and Row
> "enrpServerPoolElementEntry
> " should have related names
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (461,4) Sequence "ENRPServerASAPAddrTableEntry" and Row
> "enrpServerASAPAddrTableE
> ntry" should have related names
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (515,4) Sequence "ENRPServerUserAddrTableEntry" and Row
> "enrpServerUserAddrTableE
> ntry" should have related names
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (560,15) Item "enrpServerUserL3Opaque" should have SIZE
> specified
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (578,4) Sequence "ENRPServerENRPAddrTableEntry" and Row
> "enrpServerENRPAddrTableE
> ntry" should have related names
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (629,4) Sequence "ENRPServerPeerEntry" and Row
> "enrpServerPeerEntry" should have
> related names
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (688,4) Sequence "ENRPServerPeerAddrTableEntry" and Row
> "enrpServerPeerAddrTableE
> ntry" should have related names
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (784,15) Item "poolElementOperationScope" should have
> SIZE specified
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (792,15) Item "poolElementPoolHandle" should have SIZE
> specified
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (1026,15) Item "poolElementUserL3Opaque" should have
> SIZE specified
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (1071,15) Item "poolUserOperationScope" should have
> SIZE specified
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (1079,15) Item "poolUserPoolHandle" should have SIZE
> specified
>
> *** 0 errors and 16 warnings in parsing

I do not have SMICng installed, but these problems should be fixed now.


> I wonder if
>
>        ::= { mib-2 xxx } -- To be IANA Assigned!!!
>
> is appropriate for an EXPERIMENTAL MIB module
> Probably want to root it under the experimental tree?

Okay, this is useful. Fixed.


> Further I see a lot of naming inconsistencies
>
> - Normally, in a MIB module we prefix all TCs with a prefix that makes it
> clear
>   which module these TCs are defined in. This is to try and avoid that the
> TC
>   names/identifiers will not conflict with any existing or future other
> TCs. Specifically for a experiemntal module you do not want to have
> conflicts with standards track MIB modules.
>   So for these
>
>    ENRPServerIdentifierType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    OperationScopeType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    PoolHandleType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    DescriptionType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    PoolElementIdentifierType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    PolicyIDType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    PolicyLoadType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    PolicyWeightType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    TransportUseType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>
>   I would add a prefix aka
>
>    RserENRPServerIdentifierType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    RserOperationScopeType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    RserPoolHandleType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    RserDescriptionType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    RserPoolElementIdentifierType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    RserPolicyIDType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    RserPolicyLoadType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    RserPolicyWeightType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
>    RserTransportUseType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION

Fixed. Prefix is now "RSerPool" for everything.


>   Or maybe Enrp is the prefix as late object naming seems toindicate.
>   But then I would also make the MIB modulename ENRP-MIB and
>   then change
>           rserpoolMIB MODULE-IDENTITY
>   into
>           enrpMIB MODULE-IDENTITY
>
>   I am also not sure I would let the TC names have a suffix of "Type".
>   But that may be personal taste.
>
> - further down in the MIB module we see another prefix
>
>        poolElementEntry OBJECT-TYPE
>
>   I would ALWAYS use the same prefix throught the MIB module!
>
> - I blieve that for this one
>    enrpServerPort OBJECT-TYPE
>    SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..65535)
>   one should use the InetPort TC from RFC4001
>
>   this is true for other PORT definitions as well

Fixed.


> - I see various writable objects that do not describe what their expected
>   persistency behaviour is

Fixed.


> -    enrpServerASAPAnnounceAddr OBJECT-TYPE
>    SYNTAX     InetAddress
>    MAX-ACCESS read-only
>    STATUS     current
>    DESCRIPTION
>    "The destination multicast IP address ASAP multicast
>    announce messages are sent to."
>
>    ::= { enrpServerEntry 9 }
>
>   RFC4001 (that defines the InetAddress TC) prescribes that the
>   DESCRIPTION clause must indicate which object of SYNTAX
>   InetAddressType controls the format of this object.

Fixed.


> - When I see somehting like
>   enrpServerENRPL3Proto OBJECT-TYPE
>   SYNTAX     InetAddressType
>   MAX-ACCESS read-only
>   STATUS     current
>   DESCRIPTION
>   "The network-layer protocol (IPv4 or IPv6) of an IP address of
>   an ENRP transport endpoint."
>
>   ::= { enrpServerENRPAddrTableEntry 2 }
>
>   Then I wonder if it would not be better to SUBTYPE the TC
>   So something like
>
>        SYNTAX     InetAddressType{ipv4(1), ipv6(2)}

Fixed.

smilint prints "warning: `InetAddressType' should not be subtyped" on this,
but this seems to be a false positive. The SCTP-MIB also uses sub-typed
InetAddressType.


>   The associated
>    enrpServerPeerL3Addr OBJECT-TYPE
>    SYNTAX     InetAddress
>
>   would then become
>    enrpServerPeerL3Addr OBJECT-TYPE
>    SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
>
>   all this assuming that you explicitly want to only support IPv4 and IPv6
> and
>   not DNS and not Scoped IPv6 addresses

Fixed.


> - According to RFC4181 this one
>          rserpoolMIBConformance OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 4 }
>    should change to
>             rserpoolMIBConformance OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 2 }

1 is used for the ENRP servers branch, 2 is used for PE branch, 3 for PU
branch. The next available number is 4.


>    I do not see a reason why the recommended MIb structure in RFC4181 would
>    not be followed.
>
> - This
>    DESCRIPTION "The group of ENRP servers"
>
>    ::= { rserpoolMIBGroups 1 }
>
>   is of course not a good DESCRITPION clause.
>   It is I think "The group of objects to manage/monitor ENRP servers."
>   or some such.
>
>   Same for otehr groups

Fixed.


> -
> Abstract
>
>    RSerPool [RFC5351] is a framework to provide reliable server pooling.
>    This document defines a SMIv2 compliant Management Information Base
>    (MIB) providing access to managed objects in an RSerPool
>    implementation.
>
> Normally, citations are not supposed to be in the abstract. But that is a
> NIB,
> The document however, does not define a MIB, but a MIB module.
> I know some people think this is a nit too. The introduction has irt right.

Okay.


> Seuritty considerations is weak. It does not state anything about the
> possible secuirty issues/concerns when peole get read and/or write
> access to the various objects.
>
> s /IPSec/IPsec/ as well
>
> I think that RFC4001 is missing from the NORMATIVE references list

Okay.


> The REVISION clause should probably contain something like
>
>    REVISION "200901221012Z" -- January 22, 2009
>    DESCRIPTION
>    "This version of the MIB module published as RFC xxxx."

I will update this.


Best regards
--
=======================================================================
 Dr. Thomas Dreibholz

 University of Duisburg-Essen,                   Room ES210
 Inst. for Experimental Mathematics              Ellernstraße 29
 Computer Networking Technology Group            D-45326 Essen/Germany
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
 E-Mail:     dreibh <at> iem.uni-due.de
 Homepage:   http://www.iem.uni-due.de/~dreibh
=======================================================================
_______________________________________________
rserpool mailing list
rserpool <at> ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/rserpool
Bert Wijnen (IETF | 5 Feb 11:46 2009
Picon

Re: Last Call: draft-ietf-rserpool-mib (Reliable ServerPooling: Management Information Base using SMIv2) toExperimental RFC)

Thanks Thomas for the quick turn-arounds. This helps a lot with context-switching.
In other words, this way I can quickly re-check (as opposed to some MIB reviews
I have done where it takes montsh for a new revision to show up).
 
The SMICng check show two naming issues left:
 
  C:\bw\smicng\work>smicng rserpool.inc
  W: f(rserpool.mi2), (761,1) Sequence "RserpoolPoolElementEntry" and Row "rserpoolPEEntry" should have related names
  W: f(rserpool.mi2), (1074,1) Sequence "RserpoolPoolUserEntry" and Row "rserpoolPUEntry" should have related names
 
  *** 0 errors and 2 warnings in parsing
 
Further, you claim:
> The normal setup (according to rfc4181) would be something like:
>
> rserpoolMIBObjects          OBJECT-IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 1 }
> rserpoolMIBConformance  OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 2 }
>
> rserpoolENRPServers       OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 1 }
> rserpoolPoolElements      OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 2 }
> rserpoolPoolUsers           OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 3 }
>
> Your new MIB module has no indertation at all.
> Not a fatal flaw, but does not help in readability.

Fixed.
 
But I do nto see that fix, do I ??
 
Bert
 
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Thursday, February 05, 2009 7:29 AM
Subject: Re: [Rserpool] Last Call: draft-ietf-rserpool-mib (Reliable ServerPooling: Management Information Base using SMIv2) toExperimental RFC)

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Dear all,

attached to this mail you find the updated version of the RSerPool MIB module.

See my comments inline.


> >> - According to RFC4181 this one
> >>          rserpoolMIBConformance OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 4 }
> >>    should change to
> >>             rserpoolMIBConformance OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 2
> >> }
> >
> > 1 is used for the ENRP servers branch, 2 is used for PE branch, 3 for PU
> > branch. The next available number is 4.

Fixed.


> The normal setup (according to rfc41`81) would be something like:
>
> rserpoolMIBObjects          OBJECT-IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 1 }
> rserpoolMIBConformance  OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 2 }
>
> rserpoolENRPServers       OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 1 }
> rserpoolPoolElements      OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 2 }
> rserpoolPoolUsers           OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 3 }
>
> Your new MIB module has no indertation at all.
> Not a fatal flaw, but does not help in readability.

Fixed.


> The new MIB module causes these SMICng warnings:
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (137,1) Sequence "RSerPoolENRPEntry" and Row
> "rserpoolENRPEntry" should have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (276,1)
> Sequence "RSerPoolENRPPoolEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPPoolEntry" should
> have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (315,1) Sequence
> "RSerPoolENRPPoolElementEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry"
> should have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (465,1) Sequence
> "RSerPoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry"
> should have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (520,1) Sequence
> "RSerPoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry"
> should have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (584,1) Sequence
> "RSerPoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry"
> should have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (636,1) Sequence
> "RSerPoolENRPPeerEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPPeerEntry" should have related
> names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (695,1) Sequence "RSerPoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry"
> and Row "rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry" should have related names W:
> f(rserpool.mi2), (753,1) Sequence "RSerPoolPoolElementEntry" and Row
> "rserpoolPEEntry" should have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (941,1)
> Sequence "RSerPoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry" and Row
> "rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry" should have related names W:
> f(rserpool.mi2), (994,1) Sequence "RSerPoolPEUserAddrTableEntry" and Row
> "rserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry" should have related names W:
> f(rserpool.mi2), (1060,1) Sequence "RSerPoolPoolUserEntry" and Row
> "rserpoolPUEntry" should have related names
>
> *** 0 errors and 12 warnings in parsing
>
> Probably cause by sticking to a better naming convention. Bit it would be
> consistent throughout. It seems likd what you have is not absolutely
> incorrect. Yet... it is certainly not following the way things are normally
> done.
>
> I think this is more what I would expect:
>
>    rserpoolENRPTable OBJECT-TYPE
>    SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPEntry
>
> Then the ENTRY spec should read like:
>
>    rserpoolENRPEntry OBJECT-TYPE
>    SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPEntry
>
> And then:
>
>    RserpoolENRPEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
>    rserpoolENRPIndex                Unsigned32,
>
>
> Same further down in the MIB module.

I replaced the prefix RSerPool by Rserpool. The warning should be fixed now.
Bert, please could you run the SMICng program again on the updated MIB module?

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.9 (GNU/Linux)

iEYEARECAAYFAkmKh3IACgkQ32BbsHYPLWVI/wCffN6IE/gABUiaqRHRCaXrcm74
ZqAAn3ETcUhzC8nPrhoMJ8QeKZ2Iv/CT
=1J4Z
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
_______________________________________________
rserpool mailing list
rserpool <at> ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/rserpool
Thomas Dreibholz | 5 Feb 07:29 2009
Picon

Re: Last Call: draft-ietf-rserpool-mib (Reliable ServerPooling: Management Information Base using SMIv2) toExperimental RFC)


Dear all,

attached to this mail you find the updated version of the RSerPool MIB module.

See my comments inline.

> >> - According to RFC4181 this one
> >>          rserpoolMIBConformance OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 4 }
> >>    should change to
> >>             rserpoolMIBConformance OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 2
> >> }
> >
> > 1 is used for the ENRP servers branch, 2 is used for PE branch, 3 for PU
> > branch. The next available number is 4.

Fixed.

> The normal setup (according to rfc41`81) would be something like:
>
> rserpoolMIBObjects          OBJECT-IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 1 }
> rserpoolMIBConformance  OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 2 }
>
> rserpoolENRPServers       OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 1 }
> rserpoolPoolElements      OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 2 }
> rserpoolPoolUsers           OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 3 }
>
> Your new MIB module has no indertation at all.
> Not a fatal flaw, but does not help in readability.

Fixed.

> The new MIB module causes these SMICng warnings:
> W: f(rserpool.mi2), (137,1) Sequence "RSerPoolENRPEntry" and Row
> "rserpoolENRPEntry" should have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (276,1)
> Sequence "RSerPoolENRPPoolEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPPoolEntry" should
> have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (315,1) Sequence
> "RSerPoolENRPPoolElementEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry"
> should have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (465,1) Sequence
> "RSerPoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry"
> should have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (520,1) Sequence
> "RSerPoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry"
> should have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (584,1) Sequence
> "RSerPoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry"
> should have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (636,1) Sequence
> "RSerPoolENRPPeerEntry" and Row "rserpoolENRPPeerEntry" should have related
> names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (695,1) Sequence "RSerPoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry"
> and Row "rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry" should have related names W:
> f(rserpool.mi2), (753,1) Sequence "RSerPoolPoolElementEntry" and Row
> "rserpoolPEEntry" should have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (941,1)
> Sequence "RSerPoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry" and Row
> "rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry" should have related names W:
> f(rserpool.mi2), (994,1) Sequence "RSerPoolPEUserAddrTableEntry" and Row
> "rserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry" should have related names W:
> f(rserpool.mi2), (1060,1) Sequence "RSerPoolPoolUserEntry" and Row
> "rserpoolPUEntry" should have related names
>
> *** 0 errors and 12 warnings in parsing
>
> Probably cause by sticking to a better naming convention. Bit it would be
> consistent throughout. It seems likd what you have is not absolutely
> incorrect. Yet... it is certainly not following the way things are normally
> done.
>
> I think this is more what I would expect:
>
>    rserpoolENRPTable OBJECT-TYPE
>    SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPEntry
>
> Then the ENTRY spec should read like:
>
>    rserpoolENRPEntry OBJECT-TYPE
>    SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPEntry
>
> And then:
>
>    RserpoolENRPEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
>    rserpoolENRPIndex                Unsigned32,
>
>
> Same further down in the MIB module.

I replaced the prefix RSerPool by Rserpool. The warning should be fixed now. 
Bert, please could you run the SMICng program again on the updated MIB module?

RSERPOOL-MIB DEFINITIONS ::= BEGIN

IMPORTS
   MODULE-IDENTITY, OBJECT-TYPE, experimental,
   TimeTicks, Unsigned32
      FROM SNMPv2-SMI
   TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
      FROM SNMPv2-TC
   MODULE-COMPLIANCE, OBJECT-GROUP
      FROM SNMPv2-CONF
   InetAddressType, InetAddress, InetPortNumber
      FROM INET-ADDRESS-MIB;

-- ## Module definition ###########################################
rserpoolMIB MODULE-IDENTITY
   LAST-UPDATED
      "200902050559Z" -- February 5, 2009
   ORGANIZATION
      "IEM-TdR, UNIVERSITY OF DUISBURG-ESSEN"
   CONTACT-INFO
      " THOMAS-DREIBHOLZ

         Postal:  University of Duisburg-Essen
                  Institute for Experimental Mathematics
                  Ellernstrasse 29
                  D-45326 Essen
                  Germany
         Phone:   +49-201-183-7637
         Fax:     +49-201-183-7673
         Email:   dreibh <at> iem.uni-due.de

      JAIWANT-MULIK

         Postal:  Delaware State University
                  CIS Department
                  1200 N. DuPont Hw
                  Dover, DE
                  USA 19904
         Phone:   +1-302-857-7910
         Fax:     +1-302-857-6552
         Email:   jaiwant <at> mulik.com"
      DESCRIPTION
         "The MIB module for managing an RSerPool implementation"
      REVISION
         "200902050559Z" -- February 5, 2009
      DESCRIPTION
         "This version of the MIB module is published as RFC xxxx"
      ::= { experimental xxxxxx } -- To be IANA Assigned!!!

-- ## RSerPool type definitions ###################################
RSerPoolENRPServerIdentifierTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "x"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "The ID of an ENRP server"
   SYNTAX       Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)

RSerPoolOperationScopeTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "1024t"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "The ID of an operation scope"
   SYNTAX       OCTET STRING (SIZE (0..65535))

RSerPoolPoolHandleTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "1024t"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "The pool handle"
   SYNTAX       OCTET STRING (SIZE (0..65535))

RSerPoolDescriptionTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "1024t"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "Description"
   SYNTAX       OCTET STRING (SIZE (0..4095))

RserpoolPoolElementIdentifierTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "x"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "The pool element ID"
   SYNTAX       Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)

RSerPoolPolicyIdentifierTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "x"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "The ID of the pool policy"
   SYNTAX       Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)

RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "d"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "The load status of a pool element"
   SYNTAX       Unsigned32 (0..4294967295)

RSerPoolPolicyWeightTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "d"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "The weight of a pool element"
   SYNTAX       Unsigned32 (0..4294967295)

RSerPoolTransportUseTypeTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION "The transport use of a pool element"
   SYNTAX       INTEGER {
      dataOnly(0),
      dataPlusControl(1)
   }

RSerPoolOpaqueAddressTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "1024t"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "Opaque address"
   SYNTAX       OCTET STRING  (SIZE (0..65535))

-- ## Top-level definitions #######################################
rserpoolENRPServers  OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 1 }
rserpoolPoolElements OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 2 }
rserpoolPoolUsers    OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 3 }

-- ################################################################
-- #### ENRP Servers Section                                   ####
-- ################################################################

-- ## Definition of the ENRP server table #########################
rserpoolENRPTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The table listing of ENRP servers."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 1 }

rserpoolENRPEntry OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An ENRP server entry in the table listing of ENRP
      servers."
   INDEX { rserpoolENRPIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
rserpoolENRPIndex                Unsigned32,
rserpoolENRPOperationScope       RSerPoolOperationScopeTC,
rserpoolENRPIdentifier           RSerPoolENRPServerIdentifierTC,
rserpoolENRPDescription          RSerPoolDescriptionTC,
rserpoolENRPUptime               TimeTicks,
rserpoolENRPPort                 InetPortNumber,
rserpoolENRPASAPAnnouncePort     InetPortNumber,
rserpoolENRPASAPAnnounceAddrType InetAddressType,
rserpoolENRPASAPAnnounceAddr     InetAddress,
rserpoolENRPENRPAnnouncePort     InetPortNumber,
rserpoolENRPENRPAnnounceAddrType InetAddressType,
rserpoolENRPENRPAnnounceAddr     InetAddress }

rserpoolENRPIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An integer to uniquely identify an ENRP server."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPOperationScope OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolOperationScopeTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The definition of the operation scope of this ENRP server."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 2 }

rserpoolENRPIdentifier OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolENRPServerIdentifierTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The ENRP server identifier of this ENRP server."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 3 }

rserpoolENRPDescription OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolDescriptionTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A textual description of this ENRP server, e.g. its location
      and a contact address of its administrator."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 4 }

rserpoolENRPUptime OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     TimeTicks
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The ENRP service uptime of this ENRP server."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 5 }

rserpoolENRPPort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The SCTP port number of the ENRP protocol endpoint of
      this ENRP server."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 6 }

rserpoolENRPASAPAnnouncePort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The destination UDP port number ASAP multicast announce
      messages are sent to."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 7 }

rserpoolENRPASAPAnnounceAddrType OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol ASAP multicast announce messages
      are sent over."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 8 }

rserpoolENRPASAPAnnounceAddr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The destination IP multicast address ASAP multicast
      announce messages are sent to. The type of this address is
      given in rserpoolENRPASAPAnnounceAddrType."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 9 }

rserpoolENRPENRPAnnouncePort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The destination UDP port number ENRP multicast announce
      messages are sent to."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 10 }

rserpoolENRPENRPAnnounceAddrType OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol ENRP multicast announce messages
      are sent over."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 11 }

rserpoolENRPENRPAnnounceAddr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The destination multicast IP address ENRP multicast
      announce messages are sent to. The type of this address
      is given in rserpoolENRPENRPAnnounceAddrType."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 12 }

-- ## Definition of the pool table ################################
rserpoolENRPPoolTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPPoolEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The table listing of pools."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 3 }

rserpoolENRPPoolEntry OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPPoolEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool entry in the table listing of pools."
   INDEX { rserpoolENRPIndex, rserpoolENRPPoolIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPPoolEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPPoolIndex  Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPPoolHandle RSerPoolPoolHandleTC }

rserpoolENRPPoolIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An integer to uniquely identify a pool."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPPoolHandle OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPoolHandleTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool handle of this pool."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolEntry 2 }

-- ## Definition of the pool element table ########################
rserpoolENRPPoolElementTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The table listing of pool elements."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 4 }

rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A pool element in the table listing of pool elements."
   INDEX {
      rserpoolENRPIndex,
      rserpoolENRPPoolIndex,
      rserpoolENRPPoolElementIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPPoolElementIndex   Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPPoolElementID      RserpoolPoolElementIdentifierTC,
   rserpoolENRPASAPTransportPort  InetPortNumber,
   rserpoolENRPUserTransportProto Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPUserTransportPort  InetPortNumber,
   rserpoolENRPUserTransportUse   RSerPoolTransportUseTypeTC,
   rserpoolENRPPolicyID           RSerPoolPolicyIdentifierTC,
   rserpoolENRPPolicyDescription  RSerPoolDescriptionTC,
   rserpoolENRPPolicyWeight       RSerPoolPolicyWeightTC,
   rserpoolENRPPolicyLoad         RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC,
   rserpoolENRPPolicyLoadDeg      RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC,
   rserpoolENRPRegistrationLife   TimeTicks,
   rserpoolENRPHomeENRPServer     RSerPoolENRPServerIdentifierTC }

rserpoolENRPPoolElementIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An integer to uniquely identify a pool element. Note,
      that uniqueness of a pool element identifier in the pool
      is not enforced, therefore this index is required here!"
   ::={ rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPPoolElementID OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolPoolElementIdentifierTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool element identifier of this pool element."
   ::={ rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 2 }

rserpoolENRPASAPTransportPort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The SCTP port number of the ASAP endpoint of this pool
      element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 3 }

rserpoolENRPUserTransportProto OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (0..255)
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The transport protocol number of the service endpoint
      of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 4 }

rserpoolENRPUserTransportPort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The transport protocol's port number of the service
      endpoint of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 5 }

rserpoolENRPUserTransportUse OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolTransportUseTypeTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The transport use of the service endpoint of this pool
      element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 6 }

rserpoolENRPPolicyID OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyIdentifierTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 7 }

rserpoolENRPPolicyDescription OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolDescriptionTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The textual description of the pool policy of this pool
      element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 8 }

rserpoolENRPPolicyWeight OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyWeightTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy's weight parameter for this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 9 }

rserpoolENRPPolicyLoad OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy's load status for this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 10 }

rserpoolENRPPolicyLoadDeg OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy's load degradation parameter for this pool
      element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 11 }

rserpoolENRPRegistrationLife OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     TimeTicks
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The registration life of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 12 }

rserpoolENRPHomeENRPServer OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolENRPServerIdentifierTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The ID of the home ENRP server of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 13 }

-- ## Definition of the ASAP transport address list table #########
rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A table listing of all IP addresses of the ASAP transport
   endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 5 }

rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry  OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An IP address of the ASAP transport endpoint."
   INDEX {
      rserpoolENRPIndex,
      rserpoolENRPPoolIndex,
      rserpoolENRPPoolElementIndex,
      rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableIndex Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPASAPL3Type         InetAddressType,
   rserpoolENRPASAPL3Addr         InetAddress }

rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A unique identifier for the IP address of an ASAP transport
      endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPASAPL3Type OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol (IPv4 or IPv6) of an IP address of
      an ASAP transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry 2 }

rserpoolENRPASAPL3Addr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The IP address of an ASAP transport endpoint. The type of
      this address is given in rserpoolENRPASAPL3Type."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry 3 }

-- ## Definition of the user transport address list table #########
rserpoolENRPUserAddrTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A table listing of all IP addresses of the user
      transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 6 }

rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry  OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
   "An IP address of the user transport endpoint."
   INDEX {
      rserpoolENRPIndex,
      rserpoolENRPPoolIndex,
      rserpoolENRPPoolElementIndex,
      rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPUserAddrTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableIndex Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPUserL3Type         InetAddressType,
   rserpoolENRPUserL3Addr         InetAddress,
   rserpoolENRPUserL3Opaque       RSerPoolOpaqueAddressTC }

rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A unique identifier for the IP address of an user transport
      endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPUserL3Type OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol (IPv4 or IPv6) of an IP address
      of an user transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry 2 }

rserpoolENRPUserL3Addr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The IP address of an user transport endpoint. The type of
      this address is given in rserpoolENRPUserL3Type."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry 3 }

rserpoolENRPUserL3Opaque OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolOpaqueAddressTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The opaque address of an user transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry 4 }

-- ## Definition of ENRP address list table #######################
rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A table listing of all IP addresses of the ENRP
      transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 7 }

rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry  OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An IP address of the ENRP transport endpoint."
   INDEX {
      rserpoolENRPIndex,
      rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableIndex Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPENRPL3Type         InetAddressType,
   rserpoolENRPENRPL3Addr         InetAddress }

rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A unique identifier for the IP address of an ENRP transport
      endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPENRPL3Type OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol (IPv4 or IPv6) of an IP address of
      an ENRP transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry 2 }

rserpoolENRPENRPL3Addr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The IP address of an ENRP transport endpoint. The type of
      this address is given in rserpoolENRPENRPL3Type."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry 3 }

-- ## Definition of peer table ####################################
rserpoolENRPPeerTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPPeerEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The table listing of a peer table."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 8 }

rserpoolENRPPeerEntry OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPPeerEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A peer entry in the table listing of a peer table."
   INDEX { rserpoolENRPPeerIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPPeerEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPPeerIndex      Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPPeerIdentifier Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPPeerPort       InetPortNumber,
   rserpoolENRPPeerLastHeard  TimeTicks }

rserpoolENRPPeerIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A unique identifier for a peer entry in the table
      listing of a peer table."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPPeerIdentifier OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The ENRP identifier of this peer."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerEntry 2 }

rserpoolENRPPeerPort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The SCTP port number of the ENRP transport endpoint of
      this peer."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerEntry 3 }

rserpoolENRPPeerLastHeard OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     TimeTicks
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The time since the reception of the last ENRP Presence
      message of this peer."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerEntry 4 }

-- ## Definition of peer address list table #######################
rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A table listing of the peer endpoint addresses."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 9 }

rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry  OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A table listing of all IP addresses of the ENRP
      transport endpoint of a peer referenced by peerIndex."
   INDEX {
      rserpoolENRPPeerIndex,
      rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableIndex Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPPeerL3Type         InetAddressType,
   rserpoolENRPPeerL3Addr         InetAddress }

rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A unique identifier for the IP address of a peer ENRP
      transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPPeerL3Type OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol (IPv4 or IPv6) of an IP address
      of a peer ENRP transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry 2 }

rserpoolENRPPeerL3Addr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The IP address of a peer ENRP transport endpoint. The type
      of this address is given in rserpoolENRPPeerL3Type."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry 3 }

-- ################################################################
-- #### Pool Elements Section                                  ####
-- ################################################################

-- ## Definition of the pool element table ########################
rserpoolPETable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolPoolElementEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The table listing of pool elements."
   ::= { rserpoolPoolElements 1 }

rserpoolPEEntry OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolPoolElementEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A pool element in the table listing of pool elements."
   INDEX { rserpoolPEIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolPETable 1 }

RserpoolPoolElementEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolPEIndex              Unsigned32,
   rserpoolPEOperationScope     RSerPoolOperationScopeTC,
   rserpoolPEPoolHandle         RSerPoolPoolHandleTC,
   rserpoolPEIdentifier         RserpoolPoolElementIdentifierTC,
   rserpoolPEDescription        RSerPoolDescriptionTC,
   rserpoolPEUptime             TimeTicks,
   rserpoolPEASAPTransportPort  InetPortNumber,
   rserpoolPEUserTransportProto Unsigned32,
   rserpoolPEUserTransportPort  InetPortNumber,
   rserpoolPEUserTransportUse   RSerPoolTransportUseTypeTC,
   rserpoolPEPolicyID           RSerPoolPolicyIdentifierTC,
   rserpoolPEPolicyDescription  RSerPoolDescriptionTC,
   rserpoolPEPolicyWeight       RSerPoolPolicyWeightTC,
   rserpoolPEPolicyLoad         RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC,
   rserpoolPEPolicyLoadDeg      RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC,
   rserpoolPERegistrationLife   TimeTicks,
   rserpoolPEHomeENRPServer     RSerPoolENRPServerIdentifierTC }

rserpoolPEIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An integer to uniquely identify a pool element. Note,
      that uniqueness of a pool element identifier in the pool
      is not enforced, therefore this index is required here!"
   ::={ rserpoolPEEntry 1 }

rserpoolPEOperationScope OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolOperationScopeTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The operation scope of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 2 }

rserpoolPEPoolHandle OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPoolHandleTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool handle of this pool element. Changing this object
      will update the pool element's pool handle and result in a
      re-registration."
   ::={ rserpoolPEEntry 3 }

rserpoolPEIdentifier OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolPoolElementIdentifierTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool element identifier of this pool element."
   ::={ rserpoolPEEntry 4 }

rserpoolPEDescription OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolDescriptionTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A textual description of this pool element, e.g. its location
      and a contact address of its administrator."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 5 }

rserpoolPEUptime OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     TimeTicks
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The ENRP service uptime of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 6 }

rserpoolPEASAPTransportPort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The SCTP port number of the ASAP endpoint of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 7 }

rserpoolPEUserTransportProto OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (0..255)
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The transport protocol number of the service endpoint
      of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 8 }

rserpoolPEUserTransportPort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The transport protocol's port number of the service
      endpoint of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 9 }

rserpoolPEUserTransportUse OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolTransportUseTypeTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The transport use of the service endpoint of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 10 }

rserpoolPEPolicyID OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyIdentifierTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy of this pool element. Changing this object
      will update the pool element's policy and result in a
      re-registration."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 11 }

rserpoolPEPolicyDescription OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolDescriptionTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The textual description of the pool policy of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 12 }

rserpoolPEPolicyWeight OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyWeightTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy's weight parameter for this pool element.
      Changing this object will update the pool element's policy
      weight setting and result in
      a re-registration."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 13 }

rserpoolPEPolicyLoad OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy's load status for this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 14 }

rserpoolPEPolicyLoadDeg OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy's load degradation parameter for this pool
      element. Changing this object will update the pool element's
      load degradation setting and result in a re-registration."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 15 }

rserpoolPERegistrationLife OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     TimeTicks
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The registration life of this pool element. Changing this
      object will update the pool element's lifetime setting and
      result in a re-registration."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 16 }

rserpoolPEHomeENRPServer OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolENRPServerIdentifierTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The ID of the home ENRP server of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 17 }

-- ## Definition of the ASAP transport address list table #########
rserpoolPEASAPAddrTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A table listing of all IP addresses of the ASAP transport
      endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolPoolElements 2 }

rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry  OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An IP address of the ASAP transport endpoint."
   INDEX {
      rserpoolPEIndex,
      rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolPEASAPAddrTable 1 }

RserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableIndex Unsigned32,
   rserpoolPEASAPL3Type         InetAddressType,
   rserpoolPEASAPL3Addr         InetAddress }

rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A unique identifier for the IP address of an ASAP transport
      endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry 1 }

rserpoolPEASAPL3Type OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol (IPv4 or IPv6) of an IP address of
      an ASAP transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry 2 }

rserpoolPEASAPL3Addr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The IP address of an ASAP transport endpoint. The type of
      this address is given in rserpoolPEASAPL3Type."
   ::= { rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry 3 }

-- ## Definition of the user transport address list table #########
rserpoolPEUserAddrTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A table listing of all IP addresses of the user
      transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolPoolElements 6 }

rserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry  OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
   "An IP address of the user transport endpoint."
   INDEX {
      rserpoolPEIndex,
      rserpoolPEUserAddrTableIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolPEUserAddrTable 1 }

RserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolPEUserAddrTableIndex Unsigned32,
   rserpoolPEUserL3Type         InetAddressType,
   rserpoolPEUserL3Addr         InetAddress,
   rserpoolPEUserL3Opaque       RSerPoolOpaqueAddressTC }

rserpoolPEUserAddrTableIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A unique identifier for the IP address of an user transport
      endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry 1 }

rserpoolPEUserL3Type OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol of an IP address of
      an user transport endpoint. Set to unknown for opaque address."
   ::= { rserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry 2 }

rserpoolPEUserL3Addr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The IP address of an user transport endpoint. The type of
      this address is given in rserpoolPEUserL3Addr."
   ::= { rserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry 3 }

rserpoolPEUserL3Opaque OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolOpaqueAddressTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The opaque address of an user transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry 4 }

-- ################################################################
-- #### Pool Users Section                                     ####
-- ################################################################

-- ## Definition of the pool user table ###########################
rserpoolPUTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolPoolUserEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The table listing of pool users."
   ::= { rserpoolPoolUsers 1 }

rserpoolPUEntry OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolPoolUserEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A pool user in the table listing of pool users."
   INDEX { rserpoolPUIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolPUTable 1 }

RserpoolPoolUserEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolPUIndex          Unsigned32,
   rserpoolPUOperationScope RSerPoolOperationScopeTC,
   rserpoolPUPoolHandle     RSerPoolPoolHandleTC,
   rserpoolPUDescription    RSerPoolDescriptionTC,
   rserpoolPUUptime         TimeTicks }

rserpoolPUIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An integer to uniquely identify a pool user."
   ::= { rserpoolPUEntry 1 }

rserpoolPUOperationScope OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolOperationScopeTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The operation scope of this pool user."
   ::= { rserpoolPUEntry 2 }

rserpoolPUPoolHandle OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPoolHandleTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool handle of this pool user. Changing this object
      will update the pool user's pool handle for all future
      sessions."
   ::={ rserpoolPUEntry 3 }

rserpoolPUDescription OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolDescriptionTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A textual description of this pool user, e.g. its location
      and a contact address of its administrator."
   ::= { rserpoolPUEntry 4 }

rserpoolPUUptime OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     TimeTicks
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The ENRP service uptime of this pool user."
   ::= { rserpoolPUEntry 5 }

-- ## MIB conformance and compliance ##############################
rserpoolMIBConformance OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 4 }

rserpoolMIBCompliances OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= {
   rserpoolMIBConformance 1
}

rserpoolMIBGroups OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= {
   rserpoolMIBConformance 2
}

rserpoolMIBCompliance MODULE-COMPLIANCE
   STATUS  current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The compliance statement for SNMP entities which implement RSerPool."
   MODULE
   MANDATORY-GROUPS {
      rserpoolENRPGroup,
      rserpoolPEGroup,
      rserpoolPUGroup }
   ::= { rserpoolMIBCompliances 1 }

rserpoolENRPGroup OBJECT-GROUP
   OBJECTS {
      rserpoolENRPOperationScope,
      rserpoolENRPIdentifier,
      rserpoolENRPDescription,
      rserpoolENRPUptime,
      rserpoolENRPPort,
      rserpoolENRPASAPAnnouncePort,
      rserpoolENRPASAPAnnounceAddr,
      rserpoolENRPASAPAnnounceAddrType,
      rserpoolENRPENRPAnnounceAddrType,
      rserpoolENRPENRPAnnouncePort,
      rserpoolENRPENRPAnnounceAddr,

      rserpoolENRPPoolHandle,
      rserpoolENRPPoolElementID,

      rserpoolENRPASAPTransportPort,
      rserpoolENRPUserTransportProto,
      rserpoolENRPUserTransportUse,
      rserpoolENRPUserTransportPort,
      rserpoolENRPPolicyID,
      rserpoolENRPPolicyDescription,
      rserpoolENRPPolicyWeight,
      rserpoolENRPPolicyLoad,
      rserpoolENRPPolicyLoadDeg,
      rserpoolENRPRegistrationLife,
      rserpoolENRPHomeENRPServer,

      rserpoolENRPASAPL3Type,
      rserpoolENRPASAPL3Addr,

      rserpoolENRPUserL3Type,
      rserpoolENRPUserL3Addr,
      rserpoolENRPUserL3Opaque,

      rserpoolENRPENRPL3Type,
      rserpoolENRPENRPL3Addr,

      rserpoolENRPPeerIdentifier,
      rserpoolENRPPeerPort,
      rserpoolENRPPeerLastHeard,
      rserpoolENRPPeerL3Type,
      rserpoolENRPPeerL3Addr }
   STATUS current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The group contains all ENRP server instances
      running on the system"
   ::= { rserpoolMIBGroups 1 }

rserpoolPEGroup OBJECT-GROUP
   OBJECTS {
      rserpoolPEOperationScope,
      rserpoolPEPoolHandle,
      rserpoolPEIdentifier,
      rserpoolPEDescription,
      rserpoolPEUptime,
      rserpoolPEASAPTransportPort,
      rserpoolPEUserTransportProto,
      rserpoolPEUserTransportPort,
      rserpoolPEUserTransportUse,
      rserpoolPEPolicyID,
      rserpoolPEPolicyDescription,
      rserpoolPEPolicyWeight,
      rserpoolPEPolicyLoad,
      rserpoolPEPolicyLoadDeg,
      rserpoolPERegistrationLife,
      rserpoolPEHomeENRPServer,

      rserpoolPEASAPL3Type,
      rserpoolPEASAPL3Addr,

      rserpoolPEUserL3Type,
      rserpoolPEUserL3Addr,
      rserpoolPEUserL3Opaque }
   STATUS current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The group contains all pool element instances
      running on the system"
   ::= { rserpoolMIBGroups 2 }

rserpoolPUGroup OBJECT-GROUP
   OBJECTS { rserpoolPUOperationScope,
      rserpoolPUPoolHandle,
      rserpoolPUDescription,
      rserpoolPUUptime }
   STATUS current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The group contains all pool user instances
      running on the system"
   ::= { rserpoolMIBGroups 3 }

END
_______________________________________________
rserpool mailing list
rserpool <at> ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/rserpool
Thomas Dreibholz | 5 Feb 12:37 2009
Picon

Re: Last Call: draft-ietf-rserpool-mib (Reliable ServerPooling: Management Information Base using SMIv2) toExperimental RFC)


Dear all,

attached to this mail, you find again the latest version of the RSerPool MIB 
module.

See my comments inline.

On Donnerstag 05 Februar 2009, Bert Wijnen (IETF) wrote:
> Thanks Thomas for the quick turn-arounds. This helps a lot with
> context-switching. In other words, this way I can quickly re-check (as
> opposed to some MIB reviews I have done where it takes montsh for a new
> revision to show up).
>
> The SMICng check show two naming issues left:
>
>   C:\bw\smicng\work>smicng rserpool.inc
>   W: f(rserpool.mi2), (761,1) Sequence "RserpoolPoolElementEntry" and Row
> "rserpoolPEEntry" should have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (1074,1)
> Sequence "RserpoolPoolUserEntry" and Row "rserpoolPUEntry" should have
> related names
>
>   *** 0 errors and 2 warnings in parsing

There warnings should be fixed now. Bert, please could you re-run the SMICng 
program?

> Further, you claim:
> > The normal setup (according to rfc4181) would be something like:
> >
> > rserpoolMIBObjects          OBJECT-IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 1 }
> > rserpoolMIBConformance  OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 2 }
> >
> > rserpoolENRPServers       OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 1 }
> > rserpoolPoolElements      OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 2 }
> > rserpoolPoolUsers           OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 3
> > }
> >
> > Your new MIB module has no indertation at all.
> > Not a fatal flaw, but does not help in readability.

Sorry, I had attached a slightly older version (without this fix) in my last 
mail. Now, it should be fixed.

Best regards
-- 
=======================================================================
 Dr. Thomas Dreibholz

 University of Duisburg-Essen,                   Room ES210
 Inst. for Experimental Mathematics              Ellernstra├če 29
 Computer Networking Technology Group            D-45326 Essen/Germany
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
 E-Mail:     dreibh <at> iem.uni-due.de
 Homepage:   http://www.iem.uni-due.de/~dreibh
=======================================================================
RSERPOOL-MIB DEFINITIONS ::= BEGIN

IMPORTS
   MODULE-IDENTITY, OBJECT-TYPE, experimental,
   TimeTicks, Unsigned32
      FROM SNMPv2-SMI
   TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
      FROM SNMPv2-TC
   MODULE-COMPLIANCE, OBJECT-GROUP
      FROM SNMPv2-CONF
   InetAddressType, InetAddress, InetPortNumber
      FROM INET-ADDRESS-MIB;

-- ## Module definition ###########################################
rserpoolMIB MODULE-IDENTITY
   LAST-UPDATED
      "200902051111Z" -- February 5, 2009
   ORGANIZATION
      "IEM-TdR, UNIVERSITY OF DUISBURG-ESSEN"
   CONTACT-INFO
      " THOMAS-DREIBHOLZ

         Postal:  University of Duisburg-Essen
                  Institute for Experimental Mathematics
                  Ellernstrasse 29
                  D-45326 Essen
                  Germany
         Phone:   +49-201-183-7637
         Fax:     +49-201-183-7673
         Email:   dreibh <at> iem.uni-due.de

      JAIWANT-MULIK

         Postal:  Delaware State University
                  CIS Department
                  1200 N. DuPont Hw
                  Dover, DE
                  USA 19904
         Phone:   +1-302-857-7910
         Fax:     +1-302-857-6552
         Email:   jaiwant <at> mulik.com"
      DESCRIPTION
         "The MIB module for managing an RSerPool implementation"
      REVISION
         "200902051111Z" -- February 5, 2009
      DESCRIPTION
         "This version of the MIB module is published as RFC xxxx"
      ::= { experimental xxxxxx } -- To be IANA Assigned!!!

-- ## RSerPool type definitions ###################################
RSerPoolENRPServerIdentifierTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "x"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "The ID of an ENRP server"
   SYNTAX       Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)

RSerPoolOperationScopeTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "1024t"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "The ID of an operation scope"
   SYNTAX       OCTET STRING (SIZE (0..65535))

RSerPoolPoolHandleTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "1024t"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "The pool handle"
   SYNTAX       OCTET STRING (SIZE (0..65535))

RSerPoolDescriptionTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "1024t"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "Description"
   SYNTAX       OCTET STRING (SIZE (0..4095))

RserpoolPoolElementIdentifierTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "x"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "The pool element ID"
   SYNTAX       Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)

RSerPoolPolicyIdentifierTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "x"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "The ID of the pool policy"
   SYNTAX       Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)

RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "d"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "The load status of a pool element"
   SYNTAX       Unsigned32 (0..4294967295)

RSerPoolPolicyWeightTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "d"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "The weight of a pool element"
   SYNTAX       Unsigned32 (0..4294967295)

RSerPoolTransportUseTypeTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION "The transport use of a pool element"
   SYNTAX       INTEGER {
      dataOnly(0),
      dataPlusControl(1)
   }

RSerPoolOpaqueAddressTC ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION
   DISPLAY-HINT "1024t"
   STATUS       current
   DESCRIPTION  "Opaque address"
   SYNTAX       OCTET STRING  (SIZE (0..65535))

-- ## Top-level definitions #######################################
rserpoolMIBObjects     OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 1 }
rserpoolMIBConformance OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 2 }

rserpoolENRPServers    OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 1 }
rserpoolPoolElements   OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 2 }
rserpoolPoolUsers      OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 3 }

-- ################################################################
-- #### ENRP Servers Section                                   ####
-- ################################################################

-- ## Definition of the ENRP server table #########################
rserpoolENRPTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The table listing of ENRP servers."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 1 }

rserpoolENRPEntry OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An ENRP server entry in the table listing of ENRP
      servers."
   INDEX { rserpoolENRPIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
rserpoolENRPIndex                Unsigned32,
rserpoolENRPOperationScope       RSerPoolOperationScopeTC,
rserpoolENRPIdentifier           RSerPoolENRPServerIdentifierTC,
rserpoolENRPDescription          RSerPoolDescriptionTC,
rserpoolENRPUptime               TimeTicks,
rserpoolENRPPort                 InetPortNumber,
rserpoolENRPASAPAnnouncePort     InetPortNumber,
rserpoolENRPASAPAnnounceAddrType InetAddressType,
rserpoolENRPASAPAnnounceAddr     InetAddress,
rserpoolENRPENRPAnnouncePort     InetPortNumber,
rserpoolENRPENRPAnnounceAddrType InetAddressType,
rserpoolENRPENRPAnnounceAddr     InetAddress }

rserpoolENRPIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An integer to uniquely identify an ENRP server."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPOperationScope OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolOperationScopeTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The definition of the operation scope of this ENRP server."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 2 }

rserpoolENRPIdentifier OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolENRPServerIdentifierTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The ENRP server identifier of this ENRP server."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 3 }

rserpoolENRPDescription OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolDescriptionTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A textual description of this ENRP server, e.g. its location
      and a contact address of its administrator."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 4 }

rserpoolENRPUptime OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     TimeTicks
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The ENRP service uptime of this ENRP server."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 5 }

rserpoolENRPPort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The SCTP port number of the ENRP protocol endpoint of
      this ENRP server."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 6 }

rserpoolENRPASAPAnnouncePort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The destination UDP port number ASAP multicast announce
      messages are sent to."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 7 }

rserpoolENRPASAPAnnounceAddrType OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol ASAP multicast announce messages
      are sent over."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 8 }

rserpoolENRPASAPAnnounceAddr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The destination IP multicast address ASAP multicast
      announce messages are sent to. The type of this address is
      given in rserpoolENRPASAPAnnounceAddrType."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 9 }

rserpoolENRPENRPAnnouncePort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The destination UDP port number ENRP multicast announce
      messages are sent to."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 10 }

rserpoolENRPENRPAnnounceAddrType OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol ENRP multicast announce messages
      are sent over."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 11 }

rserpoolENRPENRPAnnounceAddr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The destination multicast IP address ENRP multicast
      announce messages are sent to. The type of this address
      is given in rserpoolENRPENRPAnnounceAddrType."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPEntry 12 }

-- ## Definition of the pool table ################################
rserpoolENRPPoolTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPPoolEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The table listing of pools."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 3 }

rserpoolENRPPoolEntry OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPPoolEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool entry in the table listing of pools."
   INDEX { rserpoolENRPIndex, rserpoolENRPPoolIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPPoolEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPPoolIndex  Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPPoolHandle RSerPoolPoolHandleTC }

rserpoolENRPPoolIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An integer to uniquely identify a pool."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPPoolHandle OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPoolHandleTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool handle of this pool."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolEntry 2 }

-- ## Definition of the pool element table ########################
rserpoolENRPPoolElementTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The table listing of pool elements."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 4 }

rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A pool element in the table listing of pool elements."
   INDEX {
      rserpoolENRPIndex,
      rserpoolENRPPoolIndex,
      rserpoolENRPPoolElementIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPPoolElementIndex   Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPPoolElementID      RserpoolPoolElementIdentifierTC,
   rserpoolENRPASAPTransportPort  InetPortNumber,
   rserpoolENRPUserTransportProto Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPUserTransportPort  InetPortNumber,
   rserpoolENRPUserTransportUse   RSerPoolTransportUseTypeTC,
   rserpoolENRPPolicyID           RSerPoolPolicyIdentifierTC,
   rserpoolENRPPolicyDescription  RSerPoolDescriptionTC,
   rserpoolENRPPolicyWeight       RSerPoolPolicyWeightTC,
   rserpoolENRPPolicyLoad         RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC,
   rserpoolENRPPolicyLoadDeg      RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC,
   rserpoolENRPRegistrationLife   TimeTicks,
   rserpoolENRPHomeENRPServer     RSerPoolENRPServerIdentifierTC }

rserpoolENRPPoolElementIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An integer to uniquely identify a pool element. Note,
      that uniqueness of a pool element identifier in the pool
      is not enforced, therefore this index is required here!"
   ::={ rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPPoolElementID OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolPoolElementIdentifierTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool element identifier of this pool element."
   ::={ rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 2 }

rserpoolENRPASAPTransportPort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The SCTP port number of the ASAP endpoint of this pool
      element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 3 }

rserpoolENRPUserTransportProto OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (0..255)
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The transport protocol number of the service endpoint
      of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 4 }

rserpoolENRPUserTransportPort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The transport protocol's port number of the service
      endpoint of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 5 }

rserpoolENRPUserTransportUse OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolTransportUseTypeTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The transport use of the service endpoint of this pool
      element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 6 }

rserpoolENRPPolicyID OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyIdentifierTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 7 }

rserpoolENRPPolicyDescription OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolDescriptionTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The textual description of the pool policy of this pool
      element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 8 }

rserpoolENRPPolicyWeight OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyWeightTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy's weight parameter for this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 9 }

rserpoolENRPPolicyLoad OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy's load status for this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 10 }

rserpoolENRPPolicyLoadDeg OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy's load degradation parameter for this pool
      element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 11 }

rserpoolENRPRegistrationLife OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     TimeTicks
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The registration life of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 12 }

rserpoolENRPHomeENRPServer OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolENRPServerIdentifierTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The ID of the home ENRP server of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPoolElementEntry 13 }

-- ## Definition of the ASAP transport address list table #########
rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A table listing of all IP addresses of the ASAP transport
   endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 5 }

rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry  OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An IP address of the ASAP transport endpoint."
   INDEX {
      rserpoolENRPIndex,
      rserpoolENRPPoolIndex,
      rserpoolENRPPoolElementIndex,
      rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableIndex Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPASAPL3Type         InetAddressType,
   rserpoolENRPASAPL3Addr         InetAddress }

rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A unique identifier for the IP address of an ASAP transport
      endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPASAPL3Type OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol (IPv4 or IPv6) of an IP address of
      an ASAP transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry 2 }

rserpoolENRPASAPL3Addr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The IP address of an ASAP transport endpoint. The type of
      this address is given in rserpoolENRPASAPL3Type."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPASAPAddrTableEntry 3 }

-- ## Definition of the user transport address list table #########
rserpoolENRPUserAddrTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A table listing of all IP addresses of the user
      transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 6 }

rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry  OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
   "An IP address of the user transport endpoint."
   INDEX {
      rserpoolENRPIndex,
      rserpoolENRPPoolIndex,
      rserpoolENRPPoolElementIndex,
      rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPUserAddrTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableIndex Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPUserL3Type         InetAddressType,
   rserpoolENRPUserL3Addr         InetAddress,
   rserpoolENRPUserL3Opaque       RSerPoolOpaqueAddressTC }

rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A unique identifier for the IP address of an user transport
      endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPUserL3Type OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol (IPv4 or IPv6) of an IP address
      of an user transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry 2 }

rserpoolENRPUserL3Addr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The IP address of an user transport endpoint. The type of
      this address is given in rserpoolENRPUserL3Type."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry 3 }

rserpoolENRPUserL3Opaque OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolOpaqueAddressTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The opaque address of an user transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPUserAddrTableEntry 4 }

-- ## Definition of ENRP address list table #######################
rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A table listing of all IP addresses of the ENRP
      transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 7 }

rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry  OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An IP address of the ENRP transport endpoint."
   INDEX {
      rserpoolENRPIndex,
      rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableIndex Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPENRPL3Type         InetAddressType,
   rserpoolENRPENRPL3Addr         InetAddress }

rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A unique identifier for the IP address of an ENRP transport
      endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPENRPL3Type OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol (IPv4 or IPv6) of an IP address of
      an ENRP transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry 2 }

rserpoolENRPENRPL3Addr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The IP address of an ENRP transport endpoint. The type of
      this address is given in rserpoolENRPENRPL3Type."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPENRPAddrTableEntry 3 }

-- ## Definition of peer table ####################################
rserpoolENRPPeerTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPPeerEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The table listing of a peer table."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 8 }

rserpoolENRPPeerEntry OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPPeerEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A peer entry in the table listing of a peer table."
   INDEX { rserpoolENRPPeerIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPPeerEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPPeerIndex      Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPPeerIdentifier Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPPeerPort       InetPortNumber,
   rserpoolENRPPeerLastHeard  TimeTicks }

rserpoolENRPPeerIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A unique identifier for a peer entry in the table
      listing of a peer table."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPPeerIdentifier OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The ENRP identifier of this peer."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerEntry 2 }

rserpoolENRPPeerPort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The SCTP port number of the ENRP transport endpoint of
      this peer."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerEntry 3 }

rserpoolENRPPeerLastHeard OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     TimeTicks
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The time since the reception of the last ENRP Presence
      message of this peer."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerEntry 4 }

-- ## Definition of peer address list table #######################
rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A table listing of the peer endpoint addresses."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPServers 9 }

rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry  OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A table listing of all IP addresses of the ENRP
      transport endpoint of a peer referenced by peerIndex."
   INDEX {
      rserpoolENRPPeerIndex,
      rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTable 1 }

RserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableIndex Unsigned32,
   rserpoolENRPPeerL3Type         InetAddressType,
   rserpoolENRPPeerL3Addr         InetAddress }

rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A unique identifier for the IP address of a peer ENRP
      transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry 1 }

rserpoolENRPPeerL3Type OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol (IPv4 or IPv6) of an IP address
      of a peer ENRP transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry 2 }

rserpoolENRPPeerL3Addr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The IP address of a peer ENRP transport endpoint. The type
      of this address is given in rserpoolENRPPeerL3Type."
   ::= { rserpoolENRPPeerAddrTableEntry 3 }

-- ################################################################
-- #### Pool Elements Section                                  ####
-- ################################################################

-- ## Definition of the pool element table ########################
rserpoolPETable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolPEEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The table listing of pool elements."
   ::= { rserpoolPoolElements 1 }

rserpoolPEEntry OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolPEEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A pool element in the table listing of pool elements."
   INDEX { rserpoolPEIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolPETable 1 }

RserpoolPEEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolPEIndex              Unsigned32,
   rserpoolPEOperationScope     RSerPoolOperationScopeTC,
   rserpoolPEPoolHandle         RSerPoolPoolHandleTC,
   rserpoolPEIdentifier         RserpoolPoolElementIdentifierTC,
   rserpoolPEDescription        RSerPoolDescriptionTC,
   rserpoolPEUptime             TimeTicks,
   rserpoolPEASAPTransportPort  InetPortNumber,
   rserpoolPEUserTransportProto Unsigned32,
   rserpoolPEUserTransportPort  InetPortNumber,
   rserpoolPEUserTransportUse   RSerPoolTransportUseTypeTC,
   rserpoolPEPolicyID           RSerPoolPolicyIdentifierTC,
   rserpoolPEPolicyDescription  RSerPoolDescriptionTC,
   rserpoolPEPolicyWeight       RSerPoolPolicyWeightTC,
   rserpoolPEPolicyLoad         RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC,
   rserpoolPEPolicyLoadDeg      RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC,
   rserpoolPERegistrationLife   TimeTicks,
   rserpoolPEHomeENRPServer     RSerPoolENRPServerIdentifierTC }

rserpoolPEIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An integer to uniquely identify a pool element. Note,
      that uniqueness of a pool element identifier in the pool
      is not enforced, therefore this index is required here!"
   ::={ rserpoolPEEntry 1 }

rserpoolPEOperationScope OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolOperationScopeTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The operation scope of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 2 }

rserpoolPEPoolHandle OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPoolHandleTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool handle of this pool element. Changing this object
      will update the pool element's pool handle and result in a
      re-registration."
   ::={ rserpoolPEEntry 3 }

rserpoolPEIdentifier OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolPoolElementIdentifierTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool element identifier of this pool element."
   ::={ rserpoolPEEntry 4 }

rserpoolPEDescription OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolDescriptionTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A textual description of this pool element, e.g. its location
      and a contact address of its administrator."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 5 }

rserpoolPEUptime OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     TimeTicks
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The ENRP service uptime of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 6 }

rserpoolPEASAPTransportPort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The SCTP port number of the ASAP endpoint of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 7 }

rserpoolPEUserTransportProto OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (0..255)
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The transport protocol number of the service endpoint
      of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 8 }

rserpoolPEUserTransportPort OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetPortNumber
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The transport protocol's port number of the service
      endpoint of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 9 }

rserpoolPEUserTransportUse OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolTransportUseTypeTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The transport use of the service endpoint of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 10 }

rserpoolPEPolicyID OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyIdentifierTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy of this pool element. Changing this object
      will update the pool element's policy and result in a
      re-registration."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 11 }

rserpoolPEPolicyDescription OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolDescriptionTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The textual description of the pool policy of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 12 }

rserpoolPEPolicyWeight OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyWeightTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy's weight parameter for this pool element.
      Changing this object will update the pool element's policy
      weight setting and result in
      a re-registration."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 13 }

rserpoolPEPolicyLoad OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy's load status for this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 14 }

rserpoolPEPolicyLoadDeg OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPolicyLoadTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool policy's load degradation parameter for this pool
      element. Changing this object will update the pool element's
      load degradation setting and result in a re-registration."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 15 }

rserpoolPERegistrationLife OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     TimeTicks
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The registration life of this pool element. Changing this
      object will update the pool element's lifetime setting and
      result in a re-registration."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 16 }

rserpoolPEHomeENRPServer OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolENRPServerIdentifierTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The ID of the home ENRP server of this pool element."
   ::= { rserpoolPEEntry 17 }

-- ## Definition of the ASAP transport address list table #########
rserpoolPEASAPAddrTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A table listing of all IP addresses of the ASAP transport
      endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolPoolElements 2 }

rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry  OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An IP address of the ASAP transport endpoint."
   INDEX {
      rserpoolPEIndex,
      rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolPEASAPAddrTable 1 }

RserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableIndex Unsigned32,
   rserpoolPEASAPL3Type         InetAddressType,
   rserpoolPEASAPL3Addr         InetAddress }

rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A unique identifier for the IP address of an ASAP transport
      endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry 1 }

rserpoolPEASAPL3Type OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol (IPv4 or IPv6) of an IP address of
      an ASAP transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry 2 }

rserpoolPEASAPL3Addr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The IP address of an ASAP transport endpoint. The type of
      this address is given in rserpoolPEASAPL3Type."
   ::= { rserpoolPEASAPAddrTableEntry 3 }

-- ## Definition of the user transport address list table #########
rserpoolPEUserAddrTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A table listing of all IP addresses of the user
      transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolPoolElements 6 }

rserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry  OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
   "An IP address of the user transport endpoint."
   INDEX {
      rserpoolPEIndex,
      rserpoolPEUserAddrTableIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolPEUserAddrTable 1 }

RserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolPEUserAddrTableIndex Unsigned32,
   rserpoolPEUserL3Type         InetAddressType,
   rserpoolPEUserL3Addr         InetAddress,
   rserpoolPEUserL3Opaque       RSerPoolOpaqueAddressTC }

rserpoolPEUserAddrTableIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A unique identifier for the IP address of an user transport
      endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry 1 }

rserpoolPEUserL3Type OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddressType { ipv4(1), ipv6(2) }
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The network-layer protocol of an IP address of
      an user transport endpoint. Set to unknown for opaque address."
   ::= { rserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry 2 }

rserpoolPEUserL3Addr OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     InetAddress (SIZE(4|16))
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The IP address of an user transport endpoint. The type of
      this address is given in rserpoolPEUserL3Addr."
   ::= { rserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry 3 }

rserpoolPEUserL3Opaque OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolOpaqueAddressTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The opaque address of an user transport endpoint."
   ::= { rserpoolPEUserAddrTableEntry 4 }

-- ################################################################
-- #### Pool Users Section                                     ####
-- ################################################################

-- ## Definition of the pool user table ###########################
rserpoolPUTable OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF RserpoolPUEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The table listing of pool users."
   ::= { rserpoolPoolUsers 1 }

rserpoolPUEntry OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RserpoolPUEntry
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A pool user in the table listing of pool users."
   INDEX { rserpoolPUIndex }
   ::= { rserpoolPUTable 1 }

RserpoolPUEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
   rserpoolPUIndex          Unsigned32,
   rserpoolPUOperationScope RSerPoolOperationScopeTC,
   rserpoolPUPoolHandle     RSerPoolPoolHandleTC,
   rserpoolPUDescription    RSerPoolDescriptionTC,
   rserpoolPUUptime         TimeTicks }

rserpoolPUIndex OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)
   MAX-ACCESS not-accessible
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "An integer to uniquely identify a pool user."
   ::= { rserpoolPUEntry 1 }

rserpoolPUOperationScope OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolOperationScopeTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The operation scope of this pool user."
   ::= { rserpoolPUEntry 2 }

rserpoolPUPoolHandle OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolPoolHandleTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The pool handle of this pool user. Changing this object
      will update the pool user's pool handle for all future
      sessions."
   ::={ rserpoolPUEntry 3 }

rserpoolPUDescription OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     RSerPoolDescriptionTC
   MAX-ACCESS read-write
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "A textual description of this pool user, e.g. its location
      and a contact address of its administrator."
   ::= { rserpoolPUEntry 4 }

rserpoolPUUptime OBJECT-TYPE
   SYNTAX     TimeTicks
   MAX-ACCESS read-only
   STATUS     current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The ENRP service uptime of this pool user."
   ::= { rserpoolPUEntry 5 }

-- ## MIB conformance and compliance ##############################
rserpoolMIBCompliances OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= {
   rserpoolMIBConformance 1
}

rserpoolMIBGroups OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= {
   rserpoolMIBConformance 2
}

rserpoolMIBCompliance MODULE-COMPLIANCE
   STATUS  current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The compliance statement for SNMP entities which implement RSerPool."
   MODULE
   MANDATORY-GROUPS {
      rserpoolENRPGroup,
      rserpoolPEGroup,
      rserpoolPUGroup }
   ::= { rserpoolMIBCompliances 1 }

rserpoolENRPGroup OBJECT-GROUP
   OBJECTS {
      rserpoolENRPOperationScope,
      rserpoolENRPIdentifier,
      rserpoolENRPDescription,
      rserpoolENRPUptime,
      rserpoolENRPPort,
      rserpoolENRPASAPAnnouncePort,
      rserpoolENRPASAPAnnounceAddr,
      rserpoolENRPASAPAnnounceAddrType,
      rserpoolENRPENRPAnnounceAddrType,
      rserpoolENRPENRPAnnouncePort,
      rserpoolENRPENRPAnnounceAddr,

      rserpoolENRPPoolHandle,
      rserpoolENRPPoolElementID,

      rserpoolENRPASAPTransportPort,
      rserpoolENRPUserTransportProto,
      rserpoolENRPUserTransportUse,
      rserpoolENRPUserTransportPort,
      rserpoolENRPPolicyID,
      rserpoolENRPPolicyDescription,
      rserpoolENRPPolicyWeight,
      rserpoolENRPPolicyLoad,
      rserpoolENRPPolicyLoadDeg,
      rserpoolENRPRegistrationLife,
      rserpoolENRPHomeENRPServer,

      rserpoolENRPASAPL3Type,
      rserpoolENRPASAPL3Addr,

      rserpoolENRPUserL3Type,
      rserpoolENRPUserL3Addr,
      rserpoolENRPUserL3Opaque,

      rserpoolENRPENRPL3Type,
      rserpoolENRPENRPL3Addr,

      rserpoolENRPPeerIdentifier,
      rserpoolENRPPeerPort,
      rserpoolENRPPeerLastHeard,
      rserpoolENRPPeerL3Type,
      rserpoolENRPPeerL3Addr }
   STATUS current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The group contains all ENRP server instances
      running on the system"
   ::= { rserpoolMIBGroups 1 }

rserpoolPEGroup OBJECT-GROUP
   OBJECTS {
      rserpoolPEOperationScope,
      rserpoolPEPoolHandle,
      rserpoolPEIdentifier,
      rserpoolPEDescription,
      rserpoolPEUptime,
      rserpoolPEASAPTransportPort,
      rserpoolPEUserTransportProto,
      rserpoolPEUserTransportPort,
      rserpoolPEUserTransportUse,
      rserpoolPEPolicyID,
      rserpoolPEPolicyDescription,
      rserpoolPEPolicyWeight,
      rserpoolPEPolicyLoad,
      rserpoolPEPolicyLoadDeg,
      rserpoolPERegistrationLife,
      rserpoolPEHomeENRPServer,

      rserpoolPEASAPL3Type,
      rserpoolPEASAPL3Addr,

      rserpoolPEUserL3Type,
      rserpoolPEUserL3Addr,
      rserpoolPEUserL3Opaque }
   STATUS current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The group contains all pool element instances
      running on the system"
   ::= { rserpoolMIBGroups 2 }

rserpoolPUGroup OBJECT-GROUP
   OBJECTS { rserpoolPUOperationScope,
      rserpoolPUPoolHandle,
      rserpoolPUDescription,
      rserpoolPUUptime }
   STATUS current
   DESCRIPTION
      "The group contains all pool user instances
      running on the system"
   ::= { rserpoolMIBGroups 3 }

END
_______________________________________________
rserpool mailing list
rserpool <at> ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/rserpool
Bert Wijnen (IETF | 5 Feb 12:41 2009
Picon

Re: Last Call: draft-ietf-rserpool-mib (Reliable ServerPooling: Management Information Base using SMIv2) toExperimental RFC)

Thanks Thomas.
The new MIB module now compiles clean.
I am happy with this version of the MIB module.
 
Bert
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Thursday, February 05, 2009 12:37 PM
Subject: Re: [Rserpool] Last Call: draft-ietf-rserpool-mib (Reliable ServerPooling: Management Information Base using SMIv2) toExperimental RFC)

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Dear all,

attached to this mail, you find again the latest version of the RSerPool MIB
module.

See my comments inline.


On Donnerstag 05 Februar 2009, Bert Wijnen (IETF) wrote:
> Thanks Thomas for the quick turn-arounds. This helps a lot with
> context-switching. In other words, this way I can quickly re-check (as
> opposed to some MIB reviews I have done where it takes montsh for a new
> revision to show up).
>
> The SMICng check show two naming issues left:
>
>   C:\bw\smicng\work>smicng rserpool.inc
>   W: f(rserpool.mi2), (761,1) Sequence "RserpoolPoolElementEntry" and Row
> "rserpoolPEEntry" should have related names W: f(rserpool.mi2), (1074,1)
> Sequence "RserpoolPoolUserEntry" and Row "rserpoolPUEntry" should have
> related names
>
>   *** 0 errors and 2 warnings in parsing

There warnings should be fixed now. Bert, please could you re-run the SMICng
program?


> Further, you claim:
> > The normal setup (according to rfc4181) would be something like:
> >
> > rserpoolMIBObjects          OBJECT-IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 1 }
> > rserpoolMIBConformance  OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIB 2 }
> >
> > rserpoolENRPServers       OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 1 }
> > rserpoolPoolElements      OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 2 }
> > rserpoolPoolUsers           OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rserpoolMIBObjects 3
> > }
> >
> > Your new MIB module has no indertation at all.
> > Not a fatal flaw, but does not help in readability.

Sorry, I had attached a slightly older version (without this fix) in my last
mail. Now, it should be fixed.


Best regards
- --
=======================================================================
 Dr. Thomas Dreibholz

 University of Duisburg-Essen,                   Room ES210
 Inst. for Experimental Mathematics              Ellernstraße 29
 Computer Networking Technology Group            D-45326 Essen/Germany
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------
 E-Mail:     dreibh <at> iem.uni-due.de
 Homepage:   http://www.iem.uni-due.de/~dreibh
=======================================================================
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.6 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQFJis+T32BbsHYPLWURApfIAKDci0+xEttdSCB9F0AodGzlnDqeDACg006U
aFwuKQxu0STd+7t04DdzbbI=
=UeB6
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
_______________________________________________
rserpool mailing list
rserpool <at> ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/rserpool
Internet-Drafts | 9 Feb 10:45 2009
Picon

I-D Action:draft-ietf-rserpool-mib-11.txt

A New Internet-Draft is available from the on-line Internet-Drafts directories.
This draft is a work item of the Reliable Server Pooling Working Group of the IETF.

	Title           : Reliable Server Pooling MIB Module Definition
	Author(s)       : T. Dreibholz, J. Mulik
	Filename        : draft-ietf-rserpool-mib-11.txt
	Pages           : 41
	Date            : 2009-02-09

Reliable Server Pooling (RSerPool) is a framework to provide reliable
server pooling.  This document defines a SMIv2 compliant Management
Information Base (MIB) module providing access to managed objects in
an RSerPool implementation.

A URL for this Internet-Draft is:
http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-ietf-rserpool-mib-11.txt

Internet-Drafts are also available by anonymous FTP at:
ftp://ftp.ietf.org/internet-drafts/

Below is the data which will enable a MIME compliant mail reader
implementation to automatically retrieve the ASCII version of the
Internet-Draft.
Attachment (draft-ietf-rserpool-mib-11.txt): message/external-body, 70 bytes
_______________________________________________
rserpool mailing list
rserpool <at> ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/rserpool

Gmane