Re: [Isis-wg] Fwd: I-D Action: draft-simpson-isis-ppp-unique-02.txt

William -

Thanx for (at last) actually including the isis-wg on this thread.

I have attached an excellent review that Mike Shand provided for your 00
draft - both as context and to insure that you have seen this (I did
forward this to you once before but am not sure you ever received it).

After reviewing the latest version (02) it seems to me that you have not
addressed any of the substance of Mike's remarks.

The most relevant changes in the 02 version consist of the revision to 

Section 3 Resolving Conflicts

As rewritten this section now says (in part):

<snip>
An implementation conforming with this specification MUST generate a
   replacement System Identifier using one of the techniques specified
   above, upon:

      (a) detecting a conflicting System Identifier in

      (a)(1) 1 IS-IS Hello from any neighbor, or

      (a)(2) 2 consecutive LSPs and/or SNPs from the same source;

      (b) failing to resolve participation in an area after