headers
Barry Leiba | 14 Jan 2011 20:18
Picon
Favicon
Gravatar

Re: WG status

> draft-ietf-sieve-include-06 - authors to do update based on comments from
> last meeting and reviews. Once done, and the shepherd (Barry) is happy, it
> can probably go to the IESG or Barry may decide another WG last call is
> needed.

I'm dredging this up.  It seems to me that the -06 version is ready.
The only comments I've seen are a suggestion from Dilyan that Jeff H
disagreed with.  Do the editors think this is ready to go to the IESG
and IETF last call?  Does the working group think so?  If I hear a few
"Let's go!" comments from the WG, and an OK from the editors, I'll do
the write-up and give it to Alexey.

Responses soon, please; I'd like to move on this now.

Barry
_______________________________________________
sieve mailing list
sieve <at> ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sieve
Permalink | Reply | 2 comments |
headers
Stephan Bosch | 25 Jan 2011 18:30
Picon

Re: WG status; include-06

Op 14-1-2011 20:18, Barry Leiba schreef:
>> draft-ietf-sieve-include-06 - authors to do update based on comments from
>> last meeting and reviews. Once done, and the shepherd (Barry) is happy, it
>> can probably go to the IESG or Barry may decide another WG last call is
>> needed.
> I'm dredging this up.  It seems to me that the -06 version is ready.
> The only comments I've seen are a suggestion from Dilyan that Jeff H
> disagreed with.  Do the editors think this is ready to go to the IESG
> and IETF last call?  Does the working group think so?  If I hear a few
> "Let's go!" comments from the WG, and an OK from the editors, I'll do
> the write-up and give it to Alexey.
>
> Responses soon, please; I'd like to move on this now.

The example script bugs are still not fixed:

   * page 9: personal spam_tests (line 5 and 9) and global spam_tests 
(line 6): reject command has no string argument
   * page 11; active script (line 3): "test-mailbox" is not a valid 
variable name
   * page 11; active script (line 14): missing require for relational 
extension, since :count is used
   * page 11; active script (line 14): the :count match type needs a 
string argument, e.g. "eq"
   * page 11; spam_filter_script (line 6): "spam-${test}; <- missing "

The script 'always_allow' on page 8 uses the `header' test for testing 
an address header, which is not a very proper example. The `address' 
test should be used, because as it is now this script will not always 
work quite as expected, e.g. when From: header is ` "Mr. Boss"
(Continue reading)

Permalink | Reply | 1 comment |
headers
Aaron Stone | 25 Jan 2011 19:06
Gravatar

Re: WG status; include-06

I'll post a new version with these corrections, thank you!

On Tue, Jan 25, 2011 at 9:30 AM, Stephan Bosch <stephan <at> rename-it.nl> wrote:
> Op 14-1-2011 20:18, Barry Leiba schreef:
>>>
>>> draft-ietf-sieve-include-06 - authors to do update based on comments from
>>> last meeting and reviews. Once done, and the shepherd (Barry) is happy,
>>> it
>>> can probably go to the IESG or Barry may decide another WG last call is
>>> needed.
>>
>> I'm dredging this up.  It seems to me that the -06 version is ready.
>> The only comments I've seen are a suggestion from Dilyan that Jeff H
>> disagreed with.  Do the editors think this is ready to go to the IESG
>> and IETF last call?  Does the working group think so?  If I hear a few
>> "Let's go!" comments from the WG, and an OK from the editors, I'll do
>> the write-up and give it to Alexey.
>>
>> Responses soon, please; I'd like to move on this now.
>
> The example script bugs are still not fixed:
>
>  * page 9: personal spam_tests (line 5 and 9) and global spam_tests (line
> 6): reject command has no string argument
>  * page 11; active script (line 3): "test-mailbox" is not a valid variable
> name
>  * page 11; active script (line 14): missing require for relational
> extension, since :count is used
>  * page 11; active script (line 14): the :count match type needs a string
> argument, e.g. "eq"
(Continue reading)

Permalink | Reply | 0 comments |

Gmane