WG Last Call For Megaco MIB

I would like to announce Working Group Last Call for the Megaco MIB.  This can be 
found at

   http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-ietf-megaco-mib-05.txt

I have also requested review by a MIB expert.

Barring major issues, Last Call will end on 16 June.

Tom Taylor,
Chair, Megaco WG.

Summary Of SG 16 Meeting Just Concluded

For your information, I have extracted the Megaco-relevant portion of the SG 16 
meeting report.  The meeting was held 20-30 May in Geneva.

3.7.3	Recommendations for Consent

New H.248.22	Shared Risk Group Package	TD-PLEN-57
New H.248.23	Enhanced Alerting Packages	TD-PLEN-32
New H.248.24	MF Tone Generation and Detection Packages	TD-PLEN-33
New H.248.25	Basic CAS Packages	TD-PLEN-58R1
New H.248.26	Enhanced Analogue Line Packages	TD-PLEN-34
New H.248.27	Supplemental Tones Packages	TD-PLEN-35

3.7.4	Documents for Approval

H.248 Supp	H.248 Sub-Series: Packages Guide Release 4	TD-PLEN-56
H.248 IG	H.248 Sub Series Implementor's Guide	TD-PLEN-36R1

3.7.6	Documents planned for Decision/Consent

3.7.6.5	H.248 Implementers Guide

TD-GEN-0035	Reply to LS on Rec. H.248 Annex E, Gain and Automatic Level Control	SG15
Addressed at the San Jose February 2003 meeting in AVD-2338. No further action needed.

D-0347	Proposed additions to H.248 Implementors' Guide	LM Ericsson
This contribution was presented and it was agreed to incorporate the two proposed 
additions into the H.248 Sub-series implementors' guide. It was also agreed that 
text should be on clarifying what should be sent in a reponse to a request that has 
only actions and no commands. This has been added as section 6.18.

Re: Summary Of SG 16 Meeting Just Concluded

Hi Tom,

Thanks for the info.
Are the output documents referred below publicly available?
If yes, where from?

Thanks
         Aleks

At 09:55 AM 6/2/2003, Tom Taylor wrote:
>For your information, I have extracted the Megaco-relevant portion of the 
>SG 16 meeting report.  The meeting was held 20-30 May in Geneva.
>
>3.7.3   Recommendations for Consent
>
>New H.248.22    Shared Risk Group Package       TD-PLEN-57
>New H.248.23    Enhanced Alerting Packages      TD-PLEN-32
>New H.248.24    MF Tone Generation and Detection Packages       TD-PLEN-33
>New H.248.25    Basic CAS Packages      TD-PLEN-58R1
>New H.248.26    Enhanced Analogue Line Packages TD-PLEN-34
>New H.248.27    Supplemental Tones Packages     TD-PLEN-35
>
>3.7.4   Documents for Approval
>
>H.248 Supp      H.248 Sub-Series: Packages Guide Release 4      TD-PLEN-56
>H.248 IG        H.248 Sub Series Implementor's Guide    TD-PLEN-36R1
>
>
>3.7.6   Documents planned for Decision/Consent
>

Re: FW: Request For MIB Review (fwd)

Megaco WG,

Bert Wijnen asked me to forward this message to the megaco
mailing list.

Mike

---------- Forwarded message ----------
Date: Mon, 2 Jun 2003 09:13:15 -0700 (PDT)
From: C. M. Heard <heard <at> pobox.com>
To: "Wijnen, Bert (Bert)" <bwijnen <at> lucent.com>
Cc: "Mreview (E-mail)" <mreview <at> ops.ietf.org>
Subject: Re: FW: Request For MIB Review

Bert,

I think that the WG should clean this document up before asking a
MIB reviewer to spend time on it.  Even after correcting a bunch of
routine syntax errors (see 2nd attachment) the MIB module does not
even come close to compiling cleanly (see 1st attachment).  It is
clear from inspection that the document has not been checked for
compliance either with http://www.ietf.org/ID-nits.html (e.g., many
lines over 80 characters on the front page ... limit is 72) or with
draft-ietf-ops-mib-review-guidelines-01.txt (e.g., REVISION clauses
don't follow the rules in section 4.5 of that document).  I also see
that requirements information is in the DESCRIPTION clauses of the
OBJECT-GROUP definitions.  As discussed here last week, it does not
belong there (we should probably add something to section 4.8 of the
guidelines doc telling people to put implementation requirements
specs in compliance statements ONLY).

Re: Summary Of SG 16 Meeting Just Concluded

Have a look at http://standard.pictel.com/ftp/avc-site/0305_Gen/.

Aleksandr Ryabin wrote:

> Hi Tom,
> 
> Thanks for the info.
> Are the output documents referred below publicly available?
> If yes, where from?
> 
> Thanks
>         Aleks
> 
> At 09:55 AM 6/2/2003, Tom Taylor wrote:
> 
>> For your information, I have extracted the Megaco-relevant portion of 
>> the SG 16 meeting report.  The meeting was held 20-30 May in Geneva.
>>
>> 3.7.3   Recommendations for Consent
>>
>> New H.248.22    Shared Risk Group Package       TD-PLEN-57
>> New H.248.23    Enhanced Alerting Packages      TD-PLEN-32
>> New H.248.24    MF Tone Generation and Detection Packages       
>> TD-PLEN-33
>> New H.248.25    Basic CAS Packages      TD-PLEN-58R1
>> New H.248.26    Enhanced Analogue Line Packages TD-PLEN-34
>> New H.248.27    Supplemental Tones Packages     TD-PLEN-35
>>
>> 3.7.4   Documents for Approval
>>

CAS pkg definition

Hello,

I could not find the email addresses of the authors of doc AVD-2315.
Hence email to this alias to get some answers.

1. Under the bcasaddr pkg also defined in the above doc., the
description for section 8.1.1 (New Property) is missing? What is this
parameter for? How will it be used?

2. Under the osext pkg defined in above doc.,in section 11.2.4/11.2.5,
what does "operator attached" and "operator released" mean? The
description is not too clear. When will these events be
notified/signaled?

Thanks.
-Malathi

Re: Summary Of SG 16 Meeting Just Concluded

I did, it only contains input documents.
Where are the output docs? e.g TD-PLEN-57, etc.?

At 03:15 PM 6/2/2003, Tom Taylor wrote:
>Have a look at http://standard.pictel.com/ftp/avc-site/0305_Gen/.
>
>Aleksandr Ryabin wrote:
>
>>Hi Tom,
>>Thanks for the info.
>>Are the output documents referred below publicly available?
>>If yes, where from?
>>Thanks
>>         Aleks
>>At 09:55 AM 6/2/2003, Tom Taylor wrote:
>>
>>>For your information, I have extracted the Megaco-relevant portion of 
>>>the SG 16 meeting report.  The meeting was held 20-30 May in Geneva.
>>>
>>>3.7.3   Recommendations for Consent
>>>
>>>New H.248.22    Shared Risk Group Package       TD-PLEN-57
>>>New H.248.23    Enhanced Alerting Packages      TD-PLEN-32
>>>New H.248.24    MF Tone Generation and Detection Packages
>>>TD-PLEN-33
>>>New H.248.25    Basic CAS Packages      TD-PLEN-58R1
>>>New H.248.26    Enhanced Analogue Line Packages TD-PLEN-34
>>>New H.248.27    Supplemental Tones Packages     TD-PLEN-35
>>>
>>>3.7.4   Documents for Approval

Re: Summary Of SG 16 Meeting Just Concluded

They will probably make it there, labelled by their Recommendation number.  One 
thing you are NOT guaranteed: that this site will contain the documents as the ITU-T 
will publish them.  The best you can hope for is a very late draft.

ITU-T members, of course, have full access to all meeting documents at the ITU-T 
site.  You do have to register individually for TIES access.

If there is general interest in a document which is a work in progress, I can see 
about translating it into an I-D for comment.

Aleksandr Ryabin wrote:

> I did, it only contains input documents.
> Where are the output docs? e.g TD-PLEN-57, etc.?
> 
> At 03:15 PM 6/2/2003, Tom Taylor wrote:
> 
>> Have a look at http://standard.pictel.com/ftp/avc-site/0305_Gen/.
>>
>> Aleksandr Ryabin wrote:
>>
>>> Hi Tom,
>>> Thanks for the info.
>>> Are the output documents referred below publicly available?
>>> If yes, where from?
>>> Thanks
>>>         Aleks
>>> At 09:55 AM 6/2/2003, Tom Taylor wrote:
>>>
>>>> For your information, I have extracted the Megaco-relevant portion 

RE: Summary Of SG 16 Meeting Just Concluded

[Fwd: RE: Summary Of SG 16 Meeting Just Concluded]

Earlier attempt didn't get to the list.

-------- Original Message --------
Subject: 	RE: [Megaco] Summary Of SG 16 Meeting Just Concluded
Date: 	Mon, 2 Jun 2003 17:13:16 -0400
From: 	Boyle, Kevin [NCRTP:3Z40:EXCH] <kboyle <at> americasm01.nt.com>
To: 	Taylor, Tom-PT [CAR:5N00:EXCH] <taylor <at> americasm01.nt.com>,
Aleksandr Ryabin <kengr <at> winphoria.com>
CC: 	Megaco List <megaco <at> ietf.org>

I uploaded the newly approved IG, and the consented text for
H.248.23-27.  They are currently in the Incoming folder, and will be
moved over to the 0305_Gen folder in the near future.

Note that these documents are completed, other than editorial changes
during the publication process.

Kevin

-----Original Message-----
From: Taylor, Tom-PT [CAR:5N00:EXCH]
Sent: Monday, June 02, 2003 4:33 PM
To: Aleksandr Ryabin
Cc: Megaco List
Subject: Re: [Megaco] Summary Of SG 16 Meeting Just Concluded

They will probably make it there, labelled by their Recommendation
number.  One
thing you are NOT guaranteed: that this site will contain the documents
as the ITU-T
will publish them.  The best you can hope for is a very late draft.

ITU-T members, of course, have full access to all meeting documents at
the ITU-T
site.  You do have to register individually for TIES access.

If there is general interest in a document which is a work in progress,
I can see
about translating it into an I-D for comment.

Aleksandr Ryabin wrote:

  > I did, it only contains input documents.
  > Where are the output docs? e.g TD-PLEN-57, etc.?
  >
  > At 03:15 PM 6/2/2003, Tom Taylor wrote:
  >
  >> Have a look at http://standard.pictel.com/ftp/avc-site/0305_Gen/.
  >>
  >> Aleksandr Ryabin wrote:
  >>
  >>> Hi Tom,
  >>> Thanks for the info.
  >>> Are the output documents referred below publicly available? If yes,
  >>> where from? Thanks
  >>>         Aleks