DIS: Re: BUS: pointless points
Kerim Aydin <kerim <at> u.washington.edu>
2014-04-14 23:20:43 GMT
On Sun, 13 Apr 2014, omd wrote:
> I hereby announce that scshunt has the highest score and has won Agora.
> AFAIK, the first part is true, as scshunt is currently ahead on
> points, with 2 proposal points plus 20 office points.
> The second part is also true; according to the Herald's report,
> scshunt has won 13 times as of February, more often than any other
> Therefore, the announcement is true, so per Rule 2419, scshunt now
> wins the game again.
> CFJ 2450 may or may not prove me wrong about this.
I think the difference (as far as I can tell) is that CFJ 2450 involved
a MAY (so it turned out to be illegal but possible to make the announcement)
while R2419 uses a 'can', albeit an uncapitalized one, (implying that
it is impossible to make such an announcement that triggers the effect).
Could be wrong though.