Jamie D. | 2 Oct 2010 05:51
Picon
Favicon

WEEKLY UPDATE:> OWNER REVIEW QUEUE as of Sept 30

 

This is the official Owner Review Edit Queue Update. Any uploads done after 7:00 PM Pacific Time on 1 Oct, 2010 will not be noted until next week's update. If you have questions about the queue please feel free to ask.

Thank you.
Jamie DeBenedetto
Edit Admin Manager

=====================================================================
EDIT Team Members OOP (Out of Pocket)

Ray until Oct 4

=================================================================
AWAITING EDIT

Jim Verzuh(1) - EGEAR DYNAMO 15-LED LANTERN – Posted Sep 13 (msg#79525),

BP - Derek Hansen - BearVault BV450 - Posted Sep 16 (msg#79540),

Joshua Reed(1) - Gerber Gator Knife - Posted Sep 16 (msg#79541), Revised Sept 20,

BP - Mike Pearl(2) - SEA TO SUMMIT X BOWL - Posted Sep 18 (msg#79552), Revised Sept 22(79567),

BP - Jerry Adams - BEAR VAULT 400 - Posted Sep 20 (msg#79556 & 79557),

BP - Derek Hansen - MSR WhisperLite Backpacking Stove - Posted Sep 23 (msg#79568),

====================================================================
TAKEN BY AN EDITOR/EDITED

RICHARD - Connor Penrod(1) - Columbia River Knife and Tool M21-14 – Posted Jul 26(msg#79353), Awaiting use clarification as of Jul 31, Revised Jul 31(79371), Taken Aug 8, Edit Aug 8(79381), Repost Aug 9, Edit Aug 9(79385), Moved to mentoring, Repost Aug 16, Edit Aug 17(79414), Repost Aug 19(79417), Edit – HTML version requested by editor Aug 26(79428), Repost Sept 11, HTML version requested by editor Sep 13(79509), Repost Sept 23, Repost Sept 26, Edit Sept 27(79582),

RAY - Drew Brandt(1) – MSR MINIWORKS EX MICROFILTER – Posted Aug 9(msg#79394), Taken Sep 1, Edit Sep 1(79459),

RICHARD - Lisa Phair(1) - Kelty Redcloud 5000 W - Posted Aug 29(msg#79452), Taken Sep 8, Edit Sept 9(79492),
=====================================================================
APPROVED AND AWAITING UPLOAD

====================================================================
REVIEWS ON HOLD

Leanne Nagy(2) - SPORT HILL 3SP POWDER PANT – Posted Sept 12(msg#79505), OR # complete, awaiting Revised version of #2 before adding to queue.

Joshua Reed(2) - Coleman Max/Peak-1 - Posted Sep 16 (msg#79542),

=================================================================
NOT ADDED to the Queue at this time

==============================================================
EDITED OR APPROVED; WAITING FOR WRITER'S ACTION

RICHARD - Andy Hintz(M)(1) - Big Agnes Insulated Air Core Sleep Pad - Posted Jul 12 (msg#79320), Taken Jul 20, Edit Jul 20 (79341), Follow up sent Aug 28, TTO Aug 28 – started new job but still interested, will repost soon,

__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
To read our reviews, please visit http://www.backpackgeartest.org/
.

__,_._,___
Jamie D. | 2 Oct 2010 05:53
Picon
Favicon

Attn: Leanne Nagy - RE: OR #2

 

Hi Leanne,

Please go through your second OR and address the things you learned from OR #1 then post a REVISED version to the yahoo group so I can add it to the Awaiting Edit section of the queue.

Thanks,
Jamie D
Edit Admin Manager

__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
To read our reviews, please visit http://www.backpackgeartest.org/
.

__,_._,___
connorpenrod | 2 Oct 2010 16:24
Picon
Favicon

Repost, OR, CRKT M21-14, Connor Penrod

 

http://tinyurl.com/2g7ttb3

Columbia River Knife and Tool M21-14
BY CONNOR PENROD
OR
July 23, 2010

TESTER INFORMATION

NAME: Connor Penrod
EMAIL: connorpenrod-/E1597aS9LQAvxtiuMwx3w@public.gmane.org
AGE: 19
LOCATION: Oceanside, California, US
GENDER: m
HEIGHT: 6' 5" (1.96 m)
WEIGHT: 188 lb (85.30 kg)

I've been hiking and camping on and off since my family and I started going to Yellowstone and Snowbird when I was a kid. I just recently started doing short excursions into the surrounding area, generally varying from trail runs of 1-3 miles (1.6-5 km) and hikes up to 6 miles (10 km). My pack weight is generally fairly light so that I can avoid grinding my knees to mush, around 10 lb (4.5 kg) at the most for runs, and up to double that for hikes. Hikes/runs are pretty arid in climate, with an occasional trip out of state to north-eastern Utah.

PRODUCT INFORMATION

Manufacturer: Columbia River Knife and Tool
Manufacturer's Website: <<HYPERLINK GOES HERE - "http://www.crkt.com" LINK TEXT = "www.crkt.com">>
MSRP: $89.99 US
Listed Weight: 5.5 oz (156 g)
Measured Weight: accurate
Listed Length: 9.25 in (23.5 cm)
Measured Length: accurate
Blade Material: AUS8
Handle Material: Charcoal anodized aluminum
Length Closed: 5.25 in (13.34 cm)
Blade Length: 4 in (10.16 cm)
Blade Thickness: .14 in (.36 cm)
Blade Style: Spearpoint with recurve. Partially serrated.
Lock Style: Liner lock with CRKT's patented AutoLawks mechanism
Opening Method: Either traditional thumb studs, or Carson Flipper

Product Description:

The M21-14 features a spear point blade with a deep belly along the cutting edge, and a false edge on top. The blade is partially serrated, and the AUS 8 steel has a satin or frost finish. Despite the false edge on top it maintains its thickness along the spine for much of the blade, of course narrowing at the tip. At the base of the blade on the spine there is jimping to help my thumb stay in place while making cuts; on the edged side at the base is an extension that acts as an index flipper/guard. When the knife is closed I can press the extension instead of the dual thumb studs to open the knife. Once it is open this extension helps keep my hand from sliding up the blade on to the knife, the extension has a small amount of jimping on the tip to keep my finger from slipping when opening the blade. On one side of the blade is the company name (CRKT) and on the other is the designer name (Kit Carson), the knife number (M21-14), area of manufacture (Taiwan), and the patent number.

The Handle is made of aluminum that is charcoal gray, and has holes cut into the aluminum slabs, CRKT refers to this as "skeletonized"; the back of the M21-14 is also completely open. The handle features a single stainless steel liner-lock that has jimping at the top; this both aids in closing and gives additional traction during use. CRKT has put in its patented "AutoLAWKS" to bolster the liner-lock. Once the knife is open and the liner-lock has popped over to keep the knife from closing, the AutoLawk (which is spring driven) drops down to stop the liner-lock from being moved back out of the way. This makes all of CRKT's knives that have this feature basically a fixed blade. The auto-lock can be lifted back up via a lever on the top right side of the handle, the liner- lock has to be manipulated back over simultaneously.
Just some other things I noticed are: Teflon bearings at the pivot point, and a Teflon coated non-multipositional pocket clip

FIELD USE

What first attracted (yes I did use attracted in reference to a knife) me to this particular knife was the leaf-shaped, drop point blade, and the index flipper which I had yet to see on a knife

I work in a retail tactical store and use the knife for cutting boxes, tape, 550cord, and any other tasks that are necessary on an almost daily basis. It handled well enough in the shop that I decided to take it with me on one of my weekly hikes so that I could test how it would perform as a survival knife.

After finding some dead wood I put it through a variety of tests, from chopping, stabbing, cutting, etc.
To start off with, this knife is not a chopper, the five minutes and rapid accumulation of blisters attest to this. As a stabbing knife it works like a dream. In either orthodox or reverse grip my hand didn't slide a millimeter and it bit fairly deep. As a cutter is where it might excel, the serrations and deep recurve to the blade cut deep with each stroke. While it may have not been the best chopper it did a fairly decent job as at splitting wood, I placed the edge on one log, then hammered the spine with another log. There were no deformations of either the spine or edge.

In testing its safety I put on a thick leather glove and did three tests, over striking in a chopping motion, striking the back spine of the blade, and stabbing with a loose grip. In both the overstriking and striking the back of the blade I could easily feel the liner lock flexing quite significantly but the secondary lock kept it from closing on itself. We sell these exact knives at the store I work at, and quite a few people complain about the secondary lock, how it is cumbersome and harder to operate in one hand. To see how the knife functioned without it I removed the secondary lock and performed the same safety tests; it snapped onto the gloves in all three. Fortunately I thought to dull the blade beforehand. After that I concluded that it is worth the extra second for the gained saf ety, besides, if I am running a race to put away my knife I'm probably doing something I shouldn't be doing; upon returning home the safety was reattached and there it shall remain.

Another interesting fact about the M21-14 is that it has a skeleton-style handle. This reduces weight, makes it easier to clean, and can give my fingers a little more purchase on the handle if my hands get slick from sweat or water.

As far as temperature ranges, it has been with me on hikes up in the Anza Borrego desert in southern California, and the Uinta Mountains in northeastern Utah with no change in performance. I would estimate temperature range of 90 F (32 C) to 35 F (2 C). Total elevation change from sea level in Oceanside to 11,068 ft in the Uinta Mountains (0-3374 meters). I usually go on three or four hikes a month, and every time this knife is clipped to the front of my pack. Over the course of nearly a year I would say it's been with me on close to 20 trips, and goes with me nearly everywhere; of course excluding school.

Of note is that in both areas, I never experienced high levels of moisture, yet the steel still managed to accumulate a small amount of surface rust. It seems to have very little corrosion resistance, I have to keep a thin film of oil on it, or it will get surface rust within hours of sweat touching it. While the skeleton style handle is a benefit in most areas, the stainless steel liner-lock is further exposed because of it. Incidentally this is the hardest area to clean and has the most surface rust. So far there are no pits it the steel anywhere though. I have to remember oil, or at least some sandpaper to scrub it with!

SUMMARY

Overall, with my testing I've concluded that the M21-14 is a jack of all trades, but a master of none. Most tasks it performs well to above average, but there was only one (safety) where I felt it excelled. My favorite aspect about this knife is how safe it is. The index flipper/index guard combined with the secondary locking mechanism mean I am never afraid of losing my fingers, and can focus on the task at hand. I know some people who have had the pleasure of having a knife close on their unprotected fingers. Quite a painful experience, and one I will continue to avoid.

I have many knives, but this is the one I'm most comfortable taking with me outdoors; both because of its many uses and its ease of cleaning.

The general versatility of the M21-14 means that it will definitely stay in my pocket for some time to come. However if I had the option of getting one with a different finish to put an extra layer between the steel surface and the eniviroment it would be a pronounced improvement. As my main survival knife it may not pass, but as a back-up it fits the bill.

<<IMAGE GOES HERE. ALT TEXT = "IMAGE" IMAGE CAPTION = "M21-14 (courtesy of CRKT)">>

<<IMAGE GOES HERE. ALT TEXT = "IMAGE 2" IMAGE CAPTION = "M21-14">>

<<IMAGE GOES HERE. ALT TEXT = "IMAGE 3" IMAGE CAPTION = "The red dot you see is the secondary lever/lock">>

THINGS I LIKE

Blade Style
Locking mechanism
Index flipper/finger guard
Edge retention
Weight

THINGS I DON'T LIKE

Non-multipostitional clip
Handle material
Not the best survival knife
Poor corrosion resistance

SIGNATURE

Connor Penrod

"There is pleasure in the pathless woods
there is rapture on the lonely shore
there is society where none intrudes
by the deep sea, and music in its roar
I love not man the less, but Nature more."

This report was created with the BGT Report Generator.
Copyright 2010. All rights reserved.

__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
To read our reviews, please visit http://www.backpackgeartest.org/
.

__,_._,___
richardglyon | 2 Oct 2010 18:18
Picon

EDIT/Approval - CRKT M21-14 - Conner Penrod

 

Conner,

Two more edits that I missed the last time, Revise accordingly and you may upload tohttp://tinyurl.com/2ambodf Be sure to click the button for an Owner Review, and to delete your Tests/OR folder copy. Thanks for sticking with this and congratulations on completing your first Owner Review!

Cheers, Richard

<<CRKT has put in its patented "AutoLAWKS" to bolster the liner-lock. Once the knife is open and the liner-lock has popped over to keep the knife from closing, the AutoLawk (which is spring driven) drops down to stop the liner-lock from being moved back out of the way. This makes all of CRKT's knives that have this feature basically a fixed blade. The auto-lock can be lifted back up via a lever on the top right side of the handle,>>
EDIT: the AutoLAWKS (which is spring driven)
EDIT: The AutoLAWKS can be lifted [Any trademark must be reproduced exactly as the manufacturer uses it - here with an "s" at the end and the last five letters capitalized.]

__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
To read our reviews, please visit http://www.backpackgeartest.org/
.

__,_._,___
Joshua Reed | 3 Oct 2010 17:28
Picon

Re: WEEKLY UPDATE:> OWNER REVIEW QUEUE as of Sept 30

 

Jamie,

I see my name on the list of reviews to be edited but I received no email telling me to edit it or what to edit. Can you direct me to the right place to re-receive these edit messages? Thank you!

Joshua reed

"Jamie D." <jdeben <at> hotmail.com> wrote:

>This is the official Owner Review Edit Queue Update. Any uploads done after 7:00 PM Pacific Time on 1 Oct, 2010 will not be noted until next week's update. If you have questions about the queue please feel free to ask.
>
>Thank you.
>Jamie DeBenedetto
>Edit Admin Manager
>
>
>=====================================================================
>EDIT Team Members OOP (Out of Pocket)
>
>Ray until Oct 4
>
>=================================================================
>AWAITING EDIT
>
>Jim Verzuh(1) - EGEAR DYNAMO 15-LED LANTERN – Posted Sep 13 (msg#79525),
>
>BP - Derek Hansen - BearVault BV450 - Posted Sep 16 (msg#79540),
>
>Joshua Reed(1) - Gerber Gator Knife - Posted Sep 16 (msg#79541), Revised Sept 20,
>
>BP - Mike Pearl(2) - SEA TO SUMMIT X BOWL - Posted Sep 18 (msg#79552), Revised Sept 22(79567),
>
>BP - Jerry Adams - BEAR VAULT 400 - Posted Sep 20 (msg#79556 & 79557),
>
>BP - Derek Hansen - MSR WhisperLite Backpacking Stove - Posted Sep 23 (msg#79568),
>
>====================================================================
>TAKEN BY AN EDITOR/EDITED
>
>RICHARD - Connor Penrod(1) - Columbia River Knife and Tool M21-14 – Posted Jul 26(msg#79353), Awaiting use clarification as of Jul 31, Revised Jul 31(79371), Taken Aug 8, Edit Aug 8(79381), Repost Aug 9, Edit Aug 9(79385), Moved to mentoring, Repost Aug 16, Edit Aug 17(79414), Repost Aug 19(79417), Edit – HTML version requested by editor Aug 26(79428), Repost Sept 11, HTML version requested by editor Sep 13(79509), Repost Sept 23, Repost Sept 26, Edit Sept 27(79582),
>
>RAY - Drew Brandt(1) – MSR MINIWORKS EX MICROFILTER – Posted Aug 9(msg#79394), Taken Sep 1, Edit Sep 1(79459),
>
>RICHARD - Lisa Phair(1) - Kelty Redcloud 5000 W - Posted Aug 29(msg#79452), Taken Sep 8, Edit Sept 9(79492),
>=====================================================================
>APPROVED AND AWAITING UPLOAD
>
>
>====================================================================
>REVIEWS ON HOLD
>
>Leanne Nagy(2) - SPORT HILL 3SP POWDER PANT – Posted Sept 12(msg#79505), OR # complete, awaiting Revised version of #2 before adding to queue.
>
>Joshua Reed(2) - Coleman Max/Peak-1 - Posted Sep 16 (msg#79542),
>
>=================================================================
>NOT ADDED to the Queue at this time
>
>
>==============================================================
>EDITED OR APPROVED; WAITING FOR WRITER'S ACTION
>
>RICHARD - Andy Hintz(M)(1) - Big Agnes Insulated Air Core Sleep Pad - Posted Jul 12 (msg#79320), Taken Jul 20, Edit Jul 20 (79341), Follow up sent Aug 28, TTO Aug 28 – started new job but still interested, will repost soon,
>
>
>
>
>

__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
To read our reviews, please visit http://www.backpackgeartest.org/
.

__,_._,___
Andrew Buskov | 3 Oct 2010 21:10

RE: WEEKLY UPDATE:> OWNER REVIEW QUEUE as of Sept 30

 

Josh,

What this means is that it's awaiting an editor to pick it up, read it, and reply with the edits. It's still in queue and will be until an editor takes it. Don't worry... it only takes a few days before an editor picks it up. If you look below at the "Taken by an editor" section, you'll note that when an editor does pick up your review, it will be moved to this section and documented as such.

AB

> >=================================================================
> >AWAITING EDIT
> >
> >Jim Verzuh(1) - EGEAR DYNAMO 15-LED LANTERN – Posted Sep 13 (msg#79525),
> >
> >BP - Derek Hansen - BearVault BV450 - Posted Sep 16 (msg#79540),
> >
> >Joshua Reed(1) - Gerber Gator Knife - Posted Sep 16 (msg#79541), Revised Sept
> 20,

> >====================================================================
> >TAKEN BY AN EDITOR/EDITED
> >
> >RAY - Drew Brandt(1) – MSR MINIWORKS EX MICROFILTER – Posted Aug 9(msg#79394),
> Taken Sep 1, Edit Sep 1(79459),

__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
To read our reviews, please visit http://www.backpackgeartest.org/
.

__,_._,___
Joshua Reed | 4 Oct 2010 01:24
Picon

RE: WEEKLY UPDATE:> OWNER REVIEW QUEUE as of Sept 30

 

Andrew,

Thanks! I just wanted to make sure I didn't miss something. Thanks again for clarifying.

Josh

Andrew Buskov <rescue <at> corridor9.net> wrote:

>Josh,
>
>What this means is that it's awaiting an editor to pick it up, read it, and reply with the edits. It's still in queue and will be until an editor takes it. Don't worry... it only takes a few days before an editor picks it up. If you look below at the "Taken by an editor" section, you'll note that when an editor does pick up your review, it will be moved to this section and documented as such.
>
>AB
>
>> >=================================================================
>> >AWAITING EDIT
>> >
>> >Jim Verzuh(1) - EGEAR DYNAMO 15-LED LANTERN – Posted Sep 13 (msg#79525),
>> >
>> >BP - Derek Hansen - BearVault BV450 - Posted Sep 16 (msg#79540),
>> >
>> >Joshua Reed(1) - Gerber Gator Knife - Posted Sep 16 (msg#79541), Revised Sept
>> 20,
>
>
>> >====================================================================
>> >TAKEN BY AN EDITOR/EDITED
>> >
>> >RAY - Drew Brandt(1) – MSR MINIWORKS EX MICROFILTER – Posted Aug 9(msg#79394),
>> Taken Sep 1, Edit Sep 1(79459),
>
>

__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
To read our reviews, please visit http://www.backpackgeartest.org/
.

__,_._,___
STEVEN | 4 Oct 2010 10:06
Picon

Owner Review - RAB Bergen Jacket - Steve Denton

 

Tiny URL - http://tiny.cc/8hsop

RAB BERGEN JACKET
BY STEVEN DENTON
OWNER REVIEW
August 22, 2010

TESTER INFORMATION
NAME: Steven Denton
EMAIL: op4u-SrPyuzuu+o61Qrn1Bg8BZw@public.gmane.org
AGE: 48
LOCATION: Bedale, North Yorkshire, United Kingdom
GENDER: m
HEIGHT: 5' 10" (1.78 m)
WEIGHT: 170 lb (77.00 kg)
CHEST 38 in (97 cm)
WAIST 32 in (81 cm)
TORSO 19 in (48 cm)
SLEEVE LENGTH 31 in (79 cm)

My average pack weight varies between 5 kg and 25 kg (11 lb - 55 lb). I go hiking in the North Yorkshire Moors and Dales as well as Mountaineering regularly in the Lake District, mostly Solo and with youth groups. My hikes include day trips lasting 5 to 10 hours as well as 3 to 5 day expeditions and wild camping. I enjoy exploring off the beaten track and in all types of weather including winter conditions. The Lake District is my favorite arena and is typically wet and windy. My favorite hiking partner is Pepsi, my dog, she is the greatest companion.

PRODUCT INFORMATION

IMAGE 1

Product Information
Manufacturer: RAB
Year of manufacture: 2007
URL: www.rab.uk.com

Men's Sizes:
S M L XL XXL
Chest
inches 37 40 43 46 48
cm 94 102 109 117 122
Waist
inches 30 32 34 36 40
cm 76 81 86 91 102
Sleeve
inches33 34 35 36 36
cm 83 86 89 91 91

IMAGE 2

Product description: I purchased the Large size jacket, although it seems it may be too big I found it to fit better. This also gave me room under the jacket to wear a good layering system under the jacket in cold weather. The Rab website describe this jacket as 'lightweight all year mountain jacket' and I could not agree more. In hot weather it can be worn effectively with just a base layer and is light enough not to cause overheating. In the cold, it is just as effective with base and mid layers and keeps out the cold winds and rain. The 3-layer Event lining performs great, keeping out wet and allowing the jacket to breathe. The cuffs are neat which tighten with hook-and-loop attachments; they are secure and feel good. The hood is also a good feature, which can be adjusted to your head, or over a beanie hat, with a wired peak it is extremely effective in high winds. What I really like about this jacket is how light it is and how it can be stuffed into a rucksack taking up little room. The front zip storm flaps work well keeping rain away from the main zip and the draw cords also work well drawing the jacket close to the body. Beware of the claimed 'sealed outer pocket', they are susceptible to leaking which is annoying.

IMAGE 4

FIELD USE

LAKE DISTRICT

IMAGE 5

Location: 3 day expedition wild camping in Langdales area of Lake District.

Location Description: The Langdales is in the heart of the Lake District and contains some of the highest and most challenging mountains in England. The terrain is varied and can be rocky, grassy, steep and extremely isolated. The weather conditions are extremely changeable making the area challenging to both hikers and their gear. Most of the 3 days I was averaging 600 m (2000 ft) rising up to 750 m (2500 ft), with the weather preventing summits being reached.

Weather Conditions: This was one of the most challenging expeditions to date, the weather was persistent heavy rain, low cloud and gale force winds for all 3 days.

The Trip:
On Day 1 the jacket was great. I wore a base layer and fleece with the jacket on top; with good use of draw cords and hook-and-loop attachments, the jacket was a nice snug fit. With carrying heavy backpacks I needed a jacket that was going to be light with good resistance to rain and high winds and the Bergen lived up to its lightweight and storm proof reputation. Straight out of the transport and on the mountain I encountered a gale force wind with horizontal rain and this jacket had some work to do. The temperature was about 6 degrees C (42 degrees F), and with a heavy backpack weighing 25 kg (55 lb), this made me sweat and the rain was pounding the outside of the jacket. So the jacket needed to get rid of sweat and resist the rain all in one go. The jacket performed brilliantly, I could not have asked for a better jacket to be honest, if I were blindfolded and wore ear defenders I would not have known it was raining. The hood and wire peak worked really well and not once the wind affected the hood. There is an adjustment on top of the hood, which works with the elastic adjusters each side and fits the head securely, and the wire peak is adjustable to suit your needs. The cuffs are secured tightly with the use of hook-and-loop attachments and the storm proof flap is also secured with hook-and-loop attachments. My clothing underneath the jacket was bone dry (apart from the sweat). The two sealed outer pockets were a weak area that I did not like, which is why there is a drainage system. They have these nice, what look to be waterproof zips, but were not very resistant to the rain. I found this frustrating, as the pockets are the few points available for stashing things without removing the jacket. They are a nice height above the rucksack waist belt and this would have been great had they been waterproof. It did not take long for the pockets to start leaking, with things becoming extremely wet in the pockets.
After wild camping, all my gear was still wet from day 1, but surprisingly the Bergen was not wet on the inside at all, but still wet on the outside. This was great and allowed me to throw on the jacket without the worry of being cold. I was now isolated in the mountains hours from civilisation, had the jacket not performed I might not have made my journey. Day 2, there was no let up in the weather and the rain was persistent for 12 hours of hiking. I could not believe how much rain had come down; this really tested the jacket to the limits. Unfortunately, the jacket eventually began to show signs of weakness with the cuffs, pockets and main zip area leaking, or seeping. This may have been partly my fault as I should have treated the jacket with Nik wax before encountering such a wet journ ey. By 8pm my mid-layers were damp, not wet, which was uncomfortable for a cold night ahead. I was disappointed, as I wanted this jacket to be good, having paid good money.
By day 3, to be fair, everything I owned that claimed to be waterproof was damp, this was a true test for gear and the only thing that survived was my tent, my trusty Big Agnes Seed house SL2. The final day was uncomfortable and would be unfair to judge the jacket because the heavy rain and gale force winds had managed to penetrate my backpack, so even the clothes under the jacket were damp along with the jacket. A good hard trek sorted out the problem of being cold and damp, now I was warm and damp. At the end of day 3 I can honestly say this was the worst 3 day hike, weather wise, and would doubt that any gear could take the pounding without leaking. To be fair once we finished and sat down the jacket dried out quickly, which was impressive and allowed me a more comfortable ride home.

NORTH YORKSHIRE MOORS

IMAGE 3

Location: 3 day expedition in North Yorkshire Moors

Location Description: The North Yorkshire Moors is moorland in Northern England with beautiful scenery, rare wildlife and unpredictable weather. The terrain is varied and can be rocky, grassy, steep and thick of bracken and heather. This expedition was about navigating point to point over a 3 day period and included overnight stays at camp sites.

Weather Conditions: Weather was extremely varied experiencing sunshine, high winds, sleet and hail, with temperatures dipping to -5 degrees C (23 degrees F).

The Trip:
Day 1 was bright sunshine with cold winds, so a good base layer and mid layer were worn under the jacket. The jacket was great, due to being lightweight, I did not overheat in the sun and the jacket was great at keeping out the wind. There was never a need to remove the jacket, as there was never a time when I felt I was overheating. The main feature was its durability after being dragged through heather and bracken, no rips and no signs of tears at all, a credit to a lightweight jacket.
Day 2 was a much colder day with driving sleet and hail, with a bitterly cold wind. With the correct under clothing, there were no issues at all and I felt warm for the whole trip. The jacket resisted all forms of weather including a bitterly cold wind, it also stayed dry inside. As the pockets are useful and easy to access with a rucksack attached I made sure this time that objects were in plastic bags as they did leak again, this sorted out my main issue with the leaking pockets.
Day 3 was pretty much cold but dry and again there were no issues, with the jacket keeping out the bitterly cold winds and being comfortable and easy to trek in.

SUMMARY

I bought the Bergen as I am a fan of RAB, and although the field conditions might seem to be critical of the jacket it was exceptional circumstances where the jacket was pounded with continuous persistent driving gale force winds and persistent heavy rain for about 36 hours in the open. I have used this jacket on many day hikes and have been really impressed, it has always kept me dry on day hikes in the rain and is great for keeping out cold winds. I do not go anywhere without the jacket and its lightness and size are great for stuffing into a rucksack when not in use. The main issue is the pockets, I cannot see the reason to even having pockets if they are susceptible to major leaking. In conclusion, this is still one of my favorite bits of kit and still goes everywhere with me, I love m y RAB Bergen and would highly recommend.

THINGS I LIKE

1. Lightweight.
2. Wind resistance.
3. The hood (Snug, keeps out the rain and does not blow off).

THINGS I DON'T LIKE

1. Leaking pockets.
2. No stuff bag (trivial but that's all I can think of).
3. Cannot think of anything significantly bad, maybe better colour coordination.

SIGNATURE

Steve Denton
This report was created with the BackpackGearTest.org Report Writer Version 1. Copyright 2010. All rights reserved.

__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
To read our reviews, please visit http://www.backpackgeartest.org/
.

__,_._,___
manta | 8 Oct 2010 01:12
Picon
Favicon

help please

 

I need help making rei's website link live in my report. does anyone know how to do this?

matthew

__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
To read our reviews, please visit http://www.backpackgeartest.org/
.

__,_._,___
Kathy Waters | 8 Oct 2010 04:10

Re: help please

 

Are you hard-coding HTML? If so, <a href-"http://www.rei.com"> REI</a> will do it

Kathy

----- Original Message -----
From: manta
To: BackpackGearTest-hHKSG33TihhbjbujkaE4pw@public.gmane.org
Sent: Thursday, October 07, 2010 5:12 PM
Subject: [BackpackGearTest] help please

I need help making rei's website link live in my report. does anyone know how to do this?

matthew

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
To read our reviews, please visit http://www.backpackgeartest.org/
.

__,_._,___

Gmane